Last updated on February 12th, 2017
Can you give me some appliance advice? I only ask because I need to buy a new washing machine. What kind to buy? A high-efficiency top-loader, or a sleek and sexy front loader?
My current model — a top loader that came with this house — is probably 20 years old. It still works, but it doesn’t work well. Furthermore, it’s stuck on the “medium” load size. Consequently I’ve had to lose weight, because the machine can’t accommodate large and extra-large loads. Of course, I can’t lose too much weight, because the washer won’t accept small or extra-small loads, either. Woe is me.
While researching washing machines, I discovered that today’s better top-loaders are “high efficiency.” They use less water than my ancient machine. They do not require any special maintenance. They are moderately priced.
Front loaders are high efficiency, too, and from reports what I’ve read, they clean clothes far better than top loaders do. They are the most expensive washing machines of all.
I visited an appliance store with the Silver Fox the other day, and he said “Why don’t you just buy the washing machine you like?”
My response: “I need to check with my readers first. They are a fount of knowledge!”
So can you help me out? In the comments field below, tell me what kind of washing machine you use, and whether or not you would recommend it. I look forward to reading your comments!
xKevin
Wanna see all of my cooking, gardening, and household posts? Get my email updates.
You may also like:
Jenn S. says
We inherited a new front loader when we bought our our, and I HATE IT WITH A PASSION. I feel like it holds less, and you have to be very careful to try out the door seal or it gets mildew! I also find it generally smells…off. I’ve taken to adding vinegar to my washes to try to combat that, so I walk around smelling like an Easter egg!
And it’s a 2012 Samsung, so it’s not like it’s very old or a weird brand! I cannot wait for it to die so I cna get a HE TOP loader!
Shirley B. says
TOP loaders.
Front loaders, for some reason; I have heard, tend to get moldy and once they do, you can’t get the smell out and your clothes begin to smell musty.
Of course, you know, once you make your decision, we’ll all be waiting with baited breath to find out, lol!
Arlene M says
Well Kevin, let me tell you how I feel!! Had a wonderful Maytag set, top loading for 15+ years. Replaced with a new front load set. I came to hate doing laundry. The worst problem was the tangle of clothes, etc. when the wash was done. The dryer was also lacking in performance. Replaced that set after only a few years. I moved on to a LG top load pair largest capacity they make 2 months ago. Love, love doing laundry again. Hope this helps. Thanks for asking.
George C. says
Front loaders are great but a quality brand like Miele or Boshe is needed to avoid the mold. Having said that stay away from any Whirlpool brands these machines are just terrible quality and break easily. However front loaders do wash clothes much better.
Cathy Olson says
I have had a Whirpool Duet front loader washer and dryer and have had no problems. I did purchase New Zealand wool dryer balls to help speed up the drying process and they work well.
Growing my own says
With a pair of needle nose vice grips you could change the washer load size. Just saying.
Terry says
I had to buy a new washer and dryer 2 years ago, and let my son talk me into a fancy Samsung HE top load washer and matching dryer. I hate them and would give anything to have back an old style like in your picture above. I do not trust this washer that uses so little water. There is no way to soak a load of really dirty clothes and have them covered with soapy water because the machine does not fill up with water. There is a cycle that said “bedding” that did use more water than the other loads but recently I got a thing in the mail that said not to use that cycle for bedding because the lid may pop open! Also, on the dryer I did not think to look, but it does not have a no heat cycle. So I cannot air things. Also, I am 5’4 and I have to stand on my tippy toes to reach things in the bottom of the washer because it is a large size and is much deeper than my old washer.
Bill says
We recently switched from a front loader to a Maytag Bravos HE top loader. Apparently, Maytag was bought out by Whirlpool a few years ago and are not as good as what one would expect from this once reliable brand. We bought it this past fall, and we have already had the Maytag repairman here twice. Luckily, the service calls were free since it is less than a year old. I am worried that something else will break soon and we won’t be covered under the warranty. It does a good job of cleaning clothes. The thing we liked about this machine was that it is big enough to clean our king sized bed coverings. We paid around $900 for it.
The front loader we had was about 15 years old. It got our clothes clean, but it also tended to wad them up. Fortunately, we never experienced mold or mildew issues with it. We typically use bleach with our whites, so perhaps that might have prevented it? One positive thing about front loaders is they save space because you can stack them. It is also easy to load and unload them.
My advice would be to find one of the traditional top loaders with an agitator. The few that are still available tend to be expensive, but imho they do the best job at cleaning clothes. They may also be the most reliable since that technology has already been perfected.
Laurel Fardoux says
I have a Frigidaire front loader washer and dryer and LOVE THEM. Have had them for about 16 years with not one problem. People are voicing concerns about mold growing in the rubber gasket, but I have never had an issue since I keep it cleaned
out as you should. I also love them because I have a counter over the top of them for folding!!! Makes my life so easy!! Good luck with your hunt!!
Jerry Miller says
Hello Kevin, I had a Fridgidaire Gallery front loader washer in Sacramento and the matching dryer. It seemed to be very efficient. It didn’t use too much soap and it didn’t fill up with too much water. It was very gentle on clothes. The spin cycle spun at a really high speed and at the end of the spin cycle, the clothes were very dry. Also, at the end of the spin cycle, the machine would reverse the direction of the spin a couple times so the clothes weren’t stuck to the side, loosening the mass of clothes, making it easier to remove the laundry. I could pack it with laundry and everything came out clean.
When I moved to Idaho, the house included a top load washer so I left my front loader in California. I really haven’t noticed a difference. Maybe with an agitator, the machine is a little more rough with the clothes, but so far I haven’t noticed any unusual wear and tear. The tub is larger than the front loader so I think it uses more water. I don’t think it spins as fast so the clothes aren’t as dry as the front loader but it’s not really that noticeable.
In conclusion, the front loader you need to bend down to get the clothes out of the machine. The top load machine can be emptied standing up. Unless you are of smaller stature (I know you’re not), a top load machine isn’t going to be difficult to empty.
My detergent usage seems to be the same for both machines and the laundry seems equally clean.
*I always put a few tablespoons of chlorine bleach in every load. I figure it disinfects the clothes but it doesn’t affect the color; kinda like the chlorine in a swimming pool. Plus, my front loader never smelled of mold.*
I guess it comes down to features and personal choice. I really don’t have a preference.
Peter says
I would go with a front loader. They use less water and have a faster spin cycle so, less drying time. To eliminate the build up of mould and mildue, just leave the door open when not in use…
Juanita trent says
I have a Whirlpool front loader. I love it I have always had top loaders until this one. No problems
Sue says
I despise my front loader. The washer is stinky (Yes, I do keep it clean, and use bleach fairly regularly), it wads clothes up (it does do the reverse spin thing at the end of the cycle, but the damage is done), and I can’t soak anything (I’m now using a bucket!). I don’t overload, but I don’t think our clothes are getting as clean as they should. I’m shopping for a new top load washer.
Nese says
I regret buying my sexy front loader. It does get a funky smell if you don’t leave the door open after running a load to dry it out. I miss being able to fill up my old top loader and let certain items like towels and whites soak for a while before washing. Also since using my front loader my kitchen towels have a sour smell when wet that which has never happened to me in 35 years of doing laundry. My vote obviously is for a top loader.
cindy corriveau says
I have a front loader now but much prefer the ol top loader type for several reasons. I used to like to soak my real dirty clothes overnight and you can’t do that with a front loader. When I want to bleach whites and leave for a few hours ,,obviously can’t do that either. I f you forget to add that one last piece of dishtowel etc you only have about 5 minutes or less to remember to add on a front loader or the cycle is locked. That does not make me happy !!. The only plus with a front loader is the claim to use less water. I also keep getting a cycle F-20 recently which means you have a to stop it mid cycle drain it and then open it up move stuff a bit then set it to rinse and drain. Definitely a bummer and i”m sick of trying to fix it. When this goes , I am definitely going back to the top loader. Less gadgets on both washer and dryer mean less will go wrong
Amy says
We just bought a house and it came with a HE top loader. I hate it – it’s far too sophisticated for my needs (it seems to have a computerized system inside and makes a noise like a computer booting up when it’s done which feels weird and disconcerting) – I would really like to have the ancient top loader with agitator that I had in my previous apartment. I’m not even sure they make those anymore 🙁
Kathy says
I replaced my top loader with the front loader. My decision was based on space, the front loader provides me with space to fold clothes or store stuff on it. If that wasn’t the issue, I would definitely get a top loader. I feel it cleans better, holds more, for performance U can’t beat a top loader!!
Tara says
I am definitely a fan of the top loader, sans agitator. We have the Whirlpool Cabrio extra large capacity but it has and sensing technology and knows the level of the load and he much water it needs to fill. The dryer has the same smart sensing technology when the clothes are dry will let you know.
My mother-in-law has a front loading machine and we discovered that thick rubber gasket around the door trap mold, bacteria and crud!
Mundi says
I have stackable Bosch washer(front load) and dryer and love them both.
The washer uses less soap and water and is gentler on fabric because it doesn’t have an agitator. I always leave my soap dispenser puled out and the door open when not in use. I also wipe down the gasket with an old hand towel and leave it in the gasket to pick up any moisture. Works a treat! No mould or mildew.
Momo says
I had a Maytag front loader for 17 years. I miss that machine. When it died, I got a high efficiency top loader. The only thing I miss is being able to shove my comforters and quilts in it. The new one can’t handle the weight. I will say that I regret not getting a Speed Queen as was suggested. They are more expensive, but are made to last. If you do go with a front loading machine, just leave the door opened between loads to avoid the funk that people complain about.
Elizabeth says
I have a Samsung front loader washer and dryer and I love them both. However, I’ll limit my discussion to the washer, since that’s what you’re concerned about.
I have had NO issues with mold or mildew, as other readers have mentioned. The trick is to dry out the machine after the last load. To do this, I simply remove the soap compartment and dry it with an old dish towel, and I leave the door to the machine open a crack so it, too, dries out. (I prop the door open with an empty TP tube.) No big deal.
Washing a load uses less than one gallon of water, but it takes about an hour to complete. The clothing/linens come out much drier than when I used my previous machine (a Maytag top loader), so the drying time has been cut in half. In the end, it takes the same amount of time to wash and dry a single load.
The regular cycle on my front-loader is comparable to the gentle cycle on my old top-loader (with an agitator), and the gentle cycle on my front-loader is as mild and gentle as hand-washing delicates in the sink.
Because the doors to the machines are low to the ground, we built a platform to set the machines on. (Otherwise, we were bending over quite a bit.) The washing machine may shake and shimmy as it spins the clothes (ours did), but that’s easily fixed by putting a small rubber pad under the legs.
I’ve had my front-loaders since January 2012, and I would not trade them for anything. I like the way they do my laundry, and I have had no problems with them at all.
Meg says
Well I’m in the minority because I like my front loader set. Firstly because they are much more efficient. Secondly because the loads come cleaner and they aren’t beaten to death by the agitator as in a top loader. I don’t get a tangled mess and things are much less wrinkled coming out. My LG brand has a “tub clean” function so mildew/mold isn’t an issue. It also has a steam clean function so I can just freshen up laundry if it has been in storage or the like. Lastly, we got the stacking kit so the dryer is on top of the washer and they are both full sized appliances occupying a small footprint. Of course that means we didn’t get the drawer bottom risers, but we don’t need them.
Good luck figuring out what you want, Kevin. Whatever you do, read the manual because these things now have so many features and functions that I didn’t know I wanted until I had them!!
Beverly, zone 6, eastern PA says
I would like to strangle the developer of the GE front loading washer I purchased 11 years ago for TOP DOLLAR, as in $1200.00. It does not have a separate spin cycle. It sits on a pedestal which is also a drawer, so its likelihood of going off balance is high. When a load finishes after an improper spin, which is TOO OFTEN FOR MY TASTE, my only recourse to rid the clothes of excess moisture is to run an 18 minute wash cycle. I repeat, THERE IS NO SPIN CYCLE. (You may say, “just remove the pedestal and sit the machine on the floor”…. but the door is low, and then I must crouch to see into the washer, or kneel to remove clothing, and my joints are not up for that.)
Next gripe, there is NO LINT CATCHER. Having a dog requires a lint catcher. We discovered after a maintenance call that the filter is internal and one must be an acrobat to remove the lower face plate to access the filter when it gets clogged. It sucks big time. Coins are the frequent culprit in blocking the filter’s ability to discharge the water. When this occurs, each load takes a huge amount of time (because the water flowing out is blocked), and most of the loads are over an hour as it is. Preposterous timetable, just pure garbage.
I blame GE squarely for this useless, experimental piece of crap. I am dutiful about mopping up the water that sits in the rubber track. I also remove the soap drawer and place it vertically into my laundry sink so it can drain and dry before being replaced. I do not have a mold smell, but only because the installer alerted me to this issue and I have been vigilant. These extra steps take time and should not be necessary, once again back to the developer.
The computer guts of the controls had to be replaced 2 years ago after months of difficulty just pressing a button and getting the wrong result. For instance, I would choose/press the highest spin out speed and the light would come on for cold water temperature, totally unrelated and located inches away from the sensor I was pressing.
At the time of purchase, I was told it would use less water and my clothes would be cleaner and there would be less wear and tear on the laundry. BUT MY NEXT WASHER WILL NOT BE A FRONT LOADER.
Where is that GE developer? Let me take a swing at him… I have been waiting since 2006 to punch his lights out.
In light of this washer torturing me, I promised myself NEVER TO BUY A GE APPLIANCE OF ANY KIND, EVER AGAIN. I have stuck to this.
Jenny C says
With a front loader, you can’t soak clothes. Which means you need a sink and wring by hand, not fun.
Tammy says
Kevin, you’ve probably had a full dose of strong opinions by now, but I’ll add my thoughts anyway 🙂 We had top-loaders for years but when our last machine died a sad and pitiful death, we opted for a front loader by Kenmore and a matching dryer. I can’t imagine ever switching back. We’ve tracked water use and it’s lower (as they promise) and we’re very happy with the condition of the clothes — no tangles, no drama, easy just to drag over right into the dryer and already kind of loosened up, unlike with top loaders. We’d read about the mold and mildew issues with front loaders and leave ours open for about 30 minutes after a load. We’re on year 9 now with the machine and have never had an odor or mold problem. Good luck with your decision!
Marcia P says
I agree with Meg’s comment above. We bought an LG front loader (it looks pretty much like your picture) about 15 months ago and I love it. Had a Maytag top loader before. Have noticed a decrease in our water bill because it does use less water. You do have to use detergent that is marked for HE machines ( less soapy). I’m short so bending over to remove the clothes doesn’t bother me that much but you can splurge and buy pedestals for them so they sit up higher. When front loaders first came out I think they did have trouble with mold but with these newer models I don’t think that is as big a problem. I do leave the washer door open for a while after washing but this LG has a magnet on the door so you can close it and it just stays open a crack to let air in and also has that “tub clean” feature too.
Good Luck shopping and let us know what you buy! Shopping for electronics, appliances, cars is not easy these days… so many changes …lol.
Linda says
I feel like the bottom line is “They don’t make them like they used to.” We have a fairly new top loader (whirlpool cabrio) and it can get stinky too. It uses less water and I feel like I always have to run the extra rinse cycle to fully rinse/clean the wash. A few times when larger items got really dirty, like when my son got chocolate all over a comforter, it did not come clean. When I took it to a laundry mat and used their front loader, all the dirt washed off, leading me to think I wanted a front loader. But it seems like they all have more cons than pros. Following.
Durf says
How nice of you to alter your weight to accommodate appliances! I’ve been wondering the same thing, Kevin. I thought I’d go with a front loader but my sister got one and it took FOREVER to finish a cycle. I’m usually desperate for clean clothes by the time I do laundry, so I need something with more immediate gratification. Other than that, I got nothing for you.
Joan says
The repairman who has fixed a number of items in my house strongly advises to stay away from the front loaders. He says they break down more often and parts are more difficult to get. I think my next washer might well be one of those European models that are washers and dryers in one. You can’t do as big a load but I rarely wash a lot of clothes at once. And European items tend to last longer than items made for the US market.
SH says
We bought an LG Washer. 4.0 cu. ft. Ultra Large Capacity Front Load Washer with ColdWash™ Technology model #WM3050CW. The matching dryer was Model number #DLE3050W. They have been in constant use for over a year. I am very happy with both. Clothes are clean and not beat up by an agitator. I have had no mold issues or odors of any kind.
Tracy says
I was afraid I would hate the efficient no agitator top load but the
LG I have is huge and does great work . I have no mold issues I only recommend a big dryer to match as. I split the heavy loads as my dryer is almost new but smaller! I do not want to over load it with the big loads. Have you picked a color? My son has georgeous grey set.
Robin Merriman says
Top loading HE – mine is a whirlpool. I absolutely love it and not qnd of the front loader issues.
badger gardener says
I like my top load washer. After I start a load I always find an item I dropped on the stairs or a shirt the kids wadded up in a corner or the dishcloth I meant to put in with the towels. Consequently, I’m always opening the top and throwing something in after the cycle has started. You can’t do this with a front loader as I found out when doing laundry at a hotel last summer.
Glad to read everyone’s opinion here as my washer / dryer combo is aging (in today’s terms, my mom has a dryer that is 40+ years old) and it won’t be long until I’m out there shopping.
Erica says
I had a top loader for about 12 years (Kleenmaid, ie Maytag), but after it finally blew up (almost literally) I replaced it with a Miele front loader. I’m very happy with it, it has a ton of washing programmes but it does not take a large doona. My machine has never developed a smell. I leave the door open after washing and I dry the inside rubber seal (as Miele advise). Once every couple of months I put a washing machine cleaner through and make sure I do a hot wash every so often. It is quiet and takes up so much less room and the drum is smooth and does not damage clothes. I have no problem with tangling and everything comes out very clean. I hope you get a machine you love Kevin.
Deb Laakso says
Go for the top loader. You work in the garden and will want to soak clothes upon occasion.
Also always always use hi efficiency soap. I recommend the Amway SA8 powder or liquid. Most of the smell and not clean complaints stem from. HE soaps that are not really HE.
Many of the front loaders throw bearings after a few years due to the residue sticking to the drum.
I have a HE top Loader and still working on the bells and whistles but it doesn’t use much water and for the most part it’s not an issue.
Tracy says
Ten years ago, I replaced my top loader washing machine, and my typical dryer, with a fancy schmancy set from LG –frontloaders.
Well. I can’t tell you how much I hated them. The washing machine didn’t clean the clothes very well and no matter how little soap I used, The weak dribbles of water never even properly covered the clothing pile, much less actually rinse anything properly. Plus the washing cycle was twice as long as my previous basic toploader. I hated the washing machine with a passion. The clothes dryer was just as bad, by the way, and just didn’t get clothes terribly dry, despite each cycle taking almost twice as long as my former basic model.
Recently, my miserable, very expensive LG front loading washing machine died, and I was never so happy to replace an appliance in my life. I chucked both the washing machine and the dryer, went to Sears, and bought the bare bones basic Sears brand (Kenmore) top loading, giant tub top loader, and basic dryer. The difference is staggering. Clothes wash in GALLONS of water, glorious water, and come out spanky clean in a flash. The machine has just enough common sense cycle options. The clothes dryer can handle huge loads of heavy towels, jeans, etc. and dries everything perfectly in half the time. Nothing has been damaged and my clothes seem just fine.
Go with a front loader, Kevin!
Mary Ellen says
I had a front load High Efficiency washer and hated it! I thought it was the last washer I would have to buy. Haha!! Asked a repairman one day what he would buy and he recommended Speed Queen. Bought both washer and dryer and have not regretted it.
Rosie S says
I have had 2 front loaders, both at different price points, and BOTH smell(ed). Yes, I keep the door open (it helps), yes I clean it….it still smells, also, it leaves the clothes in a wad, and has no better cleaning powers, imho. I would go to a top loader again, in a flash! Both front loaders have/had balance issues, but the cheaper one is definitely worse. Hope you have good luck finding your dream machine!
Jan says
I have had a Kenmore front loader for more than ten years now and love it. My husband has back issues so we also purchased the very-pricey-how-much-is-your-back-worth risers that went with the washer and dryer to help mitigate his issues. To prevent the smell that others have talked about, I put a cup of vinegar in the washer with one load every week, usually the whites. This keeps the drum fresh. I also take a rag and dry out the water that accumulates inside the rubber seal EVERY time I finish doing a load(s). This is where the source of odors can really take hold. Every now and again I spritz down the inside of the seal with vinegar. So far, no smell. Cleans well, low water use, pretty much a good experience overall. Would I buy one again? Probably.
Sylvia C. Shelnutt says
Front loader! I have Whirlpool washer and dryer both on the stands. The stands have a built-in drawer. I have had them 6 or 8 years and love them and never have had a problem. I see in the comments a mention of mildew in the front loader washer. My laundry room is situated in such a way that there is no traffic flow through the room so the door of my washer stays open when it is not in use.
Emily says
When our old top load washer started to leak, we had a repairman out. The repair was over half the cost of a new machine. I told him I thought we’d get a Fisher & Paykel washer (to match the dryer), and what did he think. He said, “I have a F & P and have put 4 parts in it in 5 years. You want a Speed Queen. It won’t save you anything on water, but it’s built like a tank.” Sold! It’s perfect for our family of 5.
Diane says
Hi Kevin,
My husband and I just went today to look at a Speed Queen top load washer after reading all the excellent reviews on-line. We will be replacing our 5-6 year old, expensive Samsung front loader, because of the funky, moldy smell that we cannot get rid of in the washer, no matter how much we clean the seal and leave the door open. The price for the Speed Queen was approx. $900.00, a bargain compared to what we paid for the Samsung front loader. Good Luck!
Judy says
I have a 20 year old Whirlpool top loader and love it. Never a problem. Lots of water temp selections and agitation speeds. My daughter HAD a front loader and she dumped it after about 5 years. She hated it. Constantly breaking, leaking or smelling. Usually all at once. She’s back to a top loader.
JanetRInn says
I have electrolux front loaders. Love them. want to marry them. Use much less water and electricity. gets all water out of clothes, which makes the drying much quicker.
I don’t understand why people don’t like them and how their clothes smell musty and mildew-y. I leave the drawer open between washes. Easy peasy. no problems.
Chris says
I think we all have a responsibility to use fewer resources where we can, including water, hot or cold, and electricity. On those counts, the front loaders win, hands down. Across the decades of an appliance’s life, the different use of water and energy really adds up. My Kenmore front loader has worked without a hitch for four years now. I find clothes come out very clean. They spin dryer than in a top loader, so dryer time is shorter. I run a sponge around the rubber gasket, then leave the door open an inch; no mold trouble at all. It seems like a pretty easy way to do a favor for the environment.
Debbie says
Front loaders are more energy and water efficient, also they are much more gentle on your clothes and you’ll find that your clothes last longer and look better. I have an LG Direct Drive and am happy with it, but don’t know if this a brand you can get in the US (I’m in Australia).
Irene says
I second the front loaders, but stick with the European brands. They’ve been in the market much longer in places where resources are limited and very expensive. I’ve had a Bosch for 7 years without any problems with the washer or smells/mold. My in-laws have had Miele’s for over 25 years without any issues. I’ve used an old Whirlpool top loader ages ago, and that thing stunk. I replaced it with a Whirlpool front loader and it stunk too.
My next washer was the Bosch and it’s been wonderful. A regular cycle takes much longer, but I do have the option of doing a quick cycle. Contrary to most of the comments, I can soak super-dirty clothes in my front loader. The trick is to start the cycle like normal with detergent, let it fill with water until it stops, let the drum turn a few times and then I turn the machine off. If I’m worried that the detergent hasn’t circulated enough, I run the cycle again so that the drum will turn a few times and then I turn the machine off again. I then run the cycle with a delayed start, usually 6 to 12 hours later, depending on how long I want the soak to go for.
I do keep the door open when not in use, use vinegar in every cycle as a fabric softener substitute. I also use a fragrance free powder detergent and the vinegar removes all detergent residue out of the clothes and washer. Look for a washer that has a drum cleaning cycle, it helps to run that every few months with vinegar. Avoid bleach, I don’t think it’s good for the gasket since it’s a very harsh chemical and cause pre-mature wear and tear.
I think most of the smell/mold issues some people have may also have to do with the detergent and fabric softener residue, mold grows faster when it has something to feed on, but if the standing water is very clean, it’ll take much longer.
Donna Greenwood says
I bought a new washer and was talked into one with no middle agitator. The load has to be perfectly balanced or it shifts to one side, won’t spin and is a complete soggy blob.
Andreas says
I loved your top loaders when I used them on a trip to visit friends in the US. BUT they use three times the amount of water that a front loader does. With water becoming more and more of a precious resource, a front loader would be the only choice for me! Front loaders have been around in Europe for a very long time, so the technology as far as efficiency and cleaning power goes has been perfected. There were top loaders in Europe too, in the early days of washing machines, but they were all superseded by front loaders, or top loaders with a drum wich rotates on a horizontal axis. You do have to use the correct washing detergent, and dose it carefully – too much is no good and too little won’t get your clothes clean. I always leave the door open after use, and I’ve never encountered a problem with smell. Yes, front loaders do take longer, but they are kinder to the clothes and to the environment. If you splash on a top of the line model such as a Miele, likelihood is that you’ll never buy another one.
wordie89 says
Had lg front load for ten years and in the beginning it was fine. Then it seemed to shake itself to unbalanced load and I’d have to fuss with it. Also clothing would “sour” faster. Began to find holes in clothes so there was probably a burr somewhere in the drum. It seemed to clean well and I liked the idea of using less water. DH very handy and after it finally failed he and engineer neighbor researched speed queen top load. Paid a little more for electronic controls as the fail rate was low. More expensive but very happy after 9 months. No smell
Deborah Goodman says
I have owned both a HE top loader and front loader. I can say with 100% certainty that you would be very unhappy with a front loader. As others have stated here a front loader does not seem to hold as much. Also the front loader I had the seal went on it and the smell!!! Even with cleaning and drying the seal around the door it , as some one else said, seemed to always smell moldy. Yuck! And yes the bending down is not enjoyable either if you are tall which I am. About the only good thing about a front loader is it is keeps the cat occupied. Yup the cat liked watching the laundry getting washed. I currently own a HE top loader. I like it much better. I know it holds more. It has a nice feature where the light blinks when you need to run washing machine cleaning through it. It doesn’t get moldy smelling. I can easily wash my queen size bedding in it. One comforter or two blankets at a time. It’s quiet. Oh and it is a Samsung. If you get the matching dryer the dryer has a sanitize cycle!!! I think the top loader gets the laundry cleaner too as compared to the front loader. Front loader didn’t seem to do a good a job. I will never ever own a front loader again!
Constantine says
We have a Samsung front loader. Have had it about 7 years. It cleans fine and has not given us problems. We leave the door open when not in use to avoid the moldy smell. It takes a long time to do a load, 1.5 hours or longer. My husband and I just bought his son a top loading Samsung HE and we prefer that to our own. When our front loader dies, we’ll go back to a top loader.
When did buying appliances become such a major chore!?
Good luck!
Marsha Smith says
Have a Frigidaire front loader that I would like to take to the dump!! If you put a small delicate load in-does not spin it well enough to hang out- so you have to use “drain and spin” mode which is a regular hard spin so using delicate is useless.
Also the mold and smell is horrible-the huge rubber ring around the opening gets “yucky” so you have to use special cleaners and leave the door and soap dispenser open-this takes up a lot of space in my narrow laundry area.
I will not replace it with a front loader.
Good Luck on your choice!
MrsGiven says
Love our Miele front-loading washer and dryer. Till this purchase, only used top loading washers. Highly recommend front loaders. The clothes come out cleaner. Things to remember, though, would be to keep the door open a crack to allow the machine to dry out after the last load, the cycles take longer on average than a top-loader, and, unlike the old-fashioned top-loaders, you can’t open the door once the cycle starts (unless it’s the first few seconds and you are willing to wait after you’ve turned the machine off).
Good luck with your shopping. Don’t forget to let us know what you purchased and how you like it.
Leslie says
I think you meant top loader in the first description there? OK – Keep it simple stupid! KISS!
I won’t bore you with the infuriating experience I had with a front loader…but I am not fond of them! I mean how much water can you really save? So, next time round – a top loader. There is one annoying feature on it I don’t like and that is not being able to just open it up to add that piece of clothing that forgot to make it in there. But in our “be safe” world can’t have Lily climbing in there and drowning can we? I also wish the new machines did not come with the curse of the computer…..more things to break, more appliance guys to call….KISS.
Good luck Kevin and heed those words of the Silver Fox coupled with common sense which I know you have plenty of, right?
Holly says
I’m on my 3 rd set of front loaders and I have a love/ hate with them. I have the washer because of its efficiency and we are on septic and I wash a whole lot of sports gear, though that has decreased with only one kid left at home! The 1st two got that nasty smell and I don’t care how much you clean them, it comes back. This time we went with the top of the line Electrolux, so far it has far exceeded my expectations- no smell, can hold big loads, has shorter wash cycles and is super quiet. With all that being said, I still love our 25 year old top loader at the lake house! Easy and old school and the clothes are clean! Lol- good luck!
Pamela says
We owned 3 front loaders that all went bad in just a couple of years. Repairs were the same price as a new machine.
This time we bought an LG top loader. It’s the biggest drum on a non commercial machine, it’s a smart washer (diagnosis is with the cell phone). It sizes up the load and dispenses the water according to that size so it’s extremely energy efficient. We love it. It’s the best machine we’ve ever owned and is a real workhorse. We know several other couples who own this machine and they feel the same way we do.
Would never want to purchase a front loader again. Too many problems, especially the mold. Always need to leave the door open and still the smell lingers. Good luck with your shopping.
gloria says
Having owned both- Buy a top loader!!!
Easy to repair- I finally just threw the front loader out-Repair guy told me 6-8 years max. Plus the moldy smell- Now I own a top loader- One teeny problem and a Different repair guy said it was fabulous and should last forever. Said to never buy a front loader! The simpler the better.
In another house we had, my old top loader died- 20 years old- guy said fix it for $750 or buy new from him or anyone for that or more- He practically swore if I fixed it I would get anther 20 years whereas a new one would be dead in 6-8.
Before you buy-Speak to local repair men- Get opinions from the guys who see the problems day after day!
Also try to get the simplest-turn on-off-type.
I just went to Sears and said I wanted the cheapest quietest-simplest-No computers. Best decision!
Mel says
I have never owned a front loader, but clean houses and use the ones in my homes I clean. The problem I see is for the money the acrylic on the front becomes scratched from wipe downs and the so called chrome starts to change colors because it is not chrome. For that very reason I would not buy because I like everything clean and shiny on the front of appliances. Since they cost so much. Rags, paper towels, anything with abrasion will eventually scratch acrylic. Go metal or glass.
L. E. Bruce says
According to my husbands research, (he asked a friend who repairs washing machines) front loaders are harder to repair and will cost way more money. So we went with water efficient top loader. I think it is fine, but he doesn’t believe it can get clothes clean with so little water.
Joan says
I have a front loader too I bought about 10 years ago and regret buying a front loader.
I too have that smell coming from it and its a hassle leaving the door open all the time.
I decided it’s time to buy a new one.
I’ll be interested to see what you decide to buy Kevin! Good luck.
Marsha Smith says
Be sure to tell us what machine you end up with.
Selma says
Hi Kevin! GE front loader is amazing! Low water usage clothes are clean and almost dry when they come out of the washer which results in quicker dryer time. Costly investment but so very worth it in the long run. Second best is Samsung front loader, be careful don’t get tricked into buying anything LE! I have one in CT that after only a few years I am disgusted with it. Clothes are very wet after spin and not clean if you put a big load in. Not true with the GE or Samsung. Good Luck! We need to conserve water so at all cost get a new high efficiency low water usage and save our planet!
Susan says
Hi Kevin, I have always had top loaders and when I moved to this house 3 years ago I inherited a Speed Queen top loader that had been in the house for about 5 years. It is a great machine. Our clothes come out clean. If I need to soak something I can. There are many choices for load size. If I just need to spin something, that can also happen. Do you really need anything more? Save your money and find the workhorse, not the sexy thing with all the bells and whistles that will break down when you need it most. Personally, I’m just happy I do not have to haul the wash to the river, beat it on the rocks and spread it on the shrubs to dry!
June says
Front loader. So energy efficient! Uses so much less water and gets clothes so much cleaner. I’ve had a Kenmore front loader for about 5 years. I leave the door open for a bit after the last load and have not had the mold problem although I live in tropical Houston. I wash everything in cold water and everything comes out perfectly clean. They are “new” in the states (relatively) but I had one when I lived in Europe 40 years ago. I missed it when we moved here.
Nancy says
Good Day, I have to disagree with some of your readers about the reliability of the front loader vs the top loader. I’m nearly 80 years old and have owned both kinds. I definitely find the front loading washing machine superior. I like it best because it is a huge water saver, and to me that is very important. Other reasons I prefer it is that it does a great job of cleaning clothes and bedding. Just be sure to get a good model that is large enough for your needs; don’t skimp. The front loader is also rugged and well built – very heavy duty machine that’s well worth the extra cost. I never look back on my choice of a front loader – wise decision.
Julie dawson says
I have had experience with both a top and a front loader. When my old style washer quit 10 years ago we switched to a maytag top load he top load. I was really disappointed in the quality of the wash. Basically the clothes sit on the bottom in a minimal amount of water and the short agitator proceeds to scrub the heck out of them as opposed to the old style where the tall agitator pulled them through a full tub of water. Also it was totally inefficient for washing anything like shoes or that sort of thing….yes I like to put my runners through a wash once in a while.
Anyway, the washer did not last well, only just over 5 years. The dryer to
that pair is still working well and I have never had a problem with it.
So… The next washer I bought is an LG front load and I LOVE it!!!
I bought the largest capacity I could at Home Depot. I have had it 2 years. My clothes are so much cleaner. I don’t have a problem with clothes tangling up in it possibly because it is large. It even does an excellent job on shoes! I have never had a problem with any odours. I occasionally use an afresh type cleaner in it but likely not as often as I should. I leave the door slightly ajar but not wide open so it’s not like you have to walk around an open door all the time. What I found interesting when I switched to a front load…. You get about 75% less lint coming off the clothes in the dryer…so it is much gentler on clothes!! I would never again go back to a top load.
Someone made a good point that front loads are nice because you have the extra space to use on top which I agree.
Other people complained about the computer noises their fron load made…. All washers are computerized and make noises now.
When I was researching what to buy I was told to stick with LG and not to get a Samsung. I went to many stores and talked to many sales people.
Anyway, hope this helps.
Lynne says
I can echo all the above front loader issues. I bought a front loader thinking I was helping the environment. It did not last long, (I think it was a Sears brand but really cant remember). I couldn’t soak clothes, it didn’t really have a “gentle” cycle, and it always smelled. I couldn’t wait to get e new top loader. broke after several
DOREEN ALEXANDER says
I purchased a Kenmore HE top loader almost 2 years ago. Like you I had the same choice you have. Decision was based on aging, mine! I could not see me bending down to add or remove clothes. It was a good choice. One note have them add an extra rinse cycle (it is worth every penny). I did because of allergies and it seems to remove every trace of soap from our clothing.
Good luck with your decision!
Carol Ogren says
I love my Samsung front loader. Mine takes large loads and works wonderfully. You must use EG soap look for EG on the soap label. When you are done with a load my instructions read to leave the door open enough for air to circulate while you dry the load and you will never have mold on your door rubber.
Cleo Jordan says
We also bought a front loader washer and dryer and HATED them so much gave them to a friend and went back to good old Amana top loader washer and front load dryer – never been happier and I do not even think about the cost of the front loader as my sanity is worth that!!
DEBBIE says
Hi Kevin and Happy Snowy day . . . AGAIN!
I actually have the LG front loading machine you have pictured above. We (family of 2) purchased the set (washer & dryer) 3 years ago and we LOVE THEM! It has a LARGE DRUM – uses LESS WATER – Uses our clothes GREAT!
I’m not sure what the others have said up there ^^^ but I wouldn’t give mine up for ANY OTHER MACHINE!
Do the right thing – read reviews – compare prices – and then go for the sexy slim-line machine 🙂
~ NOTE: as for the moldy smell people talk about??? IT’s an EASY CURE- I let my door open just a little for air circulation. NO MOLD HERE!
***PLEASE DO inform us of your choice***
Liz says
I’m in the front-loader camp, for many of the reasons outlined in earlier comments, but here’s one (frivolous) reason to go with that choice:
Lily will LOVE watching the clothes do their thing. It’s like doggy TV. Our dogs and especially our cats sit in front of the thing like they’re watching Saturday morning cartoons. Will the clothes flop to the right? No, wait, it’s switching direction, and they’re flopping left!
Matthew Davis says
I am in the market myself and the research I have done is not good. It seems planned obsolescence is the rule of the day and they just don’t make em like they used to. After reading countless reviews and comments they all sound bad. There is perhaps one exception. Simple is good. Machines with all the bells and whistles have more to break. That being said the very simple mechanical Speed Queen has changed little and is still prized for longevity and durability.
ingmarie peck says
Top loader, absolutely,several cycles, multi functional and no mold growing.
I love mine, small loads big loads ,rinses or just spins. Works for me.
Moyra says
I don’t think you can open the door to add something with a front loader…I quite often do that, so I stick with a top loader!
Alice&Keith says
It has been interesting to read all the comments.
I am a Massage Therapist, working in my home, and my husband works outside in all weather. Our laundry routine can very from one load a week to 5 loads a day (with the latter being more the norm). I needed equipment that could withstand the rigors of 5 loads a day for the remainder of our days!
I ended up with a Speed Queen, top-loading, large capacity, heavy duty washer; and an Amana large capacity dryer (with air dry option). I have not looked back. Instead of 5-loads a day, I can wash the sheets in just two loads. And I have not had a moments issue with either. We have even had a move since purchasing them three years ago.
On the other hand, our son purchased the fancy top-loading Maytag HE matching set, with all the bells and whistles and in one year, the computer board had to be replaced three times. No thank you to electronics in laundry equipment.
bren english says
I have had both and highly recommend the front loader for theses reasons:
efficient with water and soap.
wash clothes cleaner
more settings
stackable–smaller footprint
always use HE soap and use 1-2 Tbsp Borax in every load-clothes are cleaner, use less HE liquid (easier on environment and clothes)-and bonus, no smell in machine ever and clothes always smell so nice!
**always, always leave the door ajar when not in use so seal can not only dry out it needs to ‘relax’ too, and lift the door ever so slightly when closing it, so as to not damage the switch pin that locks it into the machine.
I will never go back to top loading machine.
Only thing I miss is that I used to dye clothes in the top loader-off on agitate etc. and I can’t do that in the front load machines.
and don’t buy the huge ones that are the size of trucks!! lol-not needed-buy the best you can afford-
Alyce Grover says
I heard front loaders are easier on fabrics.
Sarah dillon says
I recently replaced my top loader with a front loader and everything was fine. I do add a bit of lemon scented ammonia to the loads once in a while and haven’t had any problem with mildew. BUT I have found it to be a real pain when I want to soak clothes in bleach. My slipcovers are white so they get the treatment at least once a year. It used to be dead easy to do with my old top loader, now not so much. So if treating your laundry in that way is part of your routine stick with a top loader.
Judy Hines says
Kevin, go for the top load washer — also those new sleek ones are too high to use to fold clothes on! Our Maytag washer and dryer are going strong but I use a cup of vinegar about every 2 months in the washer and they are going on 20 years old!!! The dryer is front load and is fine.
Bill Halsey says
We have had a couple Maytag top-loaders over the years, which worked fine. On the advice of an ex-Whirlpool engineer, we purchased an LG front-loader of modest size a few years ago. We are very happy with it, indeed. Not sure what all this business about mold is about, we’ve not ever experienced that. We just stuff a small hand towel into the bottom of the front seal to absorb moisture while unloading, then hang it up to dry.
Having been a mechanical designer myself I appreciate the LG direct-drive setup with no gearbox, belts, or any of that to wear & fail. As with any machine, keep the load at a reasonable size and it won’t have problems.
Very efficient and we never use a dryer, as this will spin the load nearly dry. I had heard that the spin cycle can cause top-loaders to vibrate and walk around — however, this LG spin cycle is so smooth, one can always balance a nickle on edge on its top while it is spinning full tilt. We hang the load indoors in winter for moisture, and outdoors in summer for that wonderful fragrance of line-dried goods.
By now, this probably reads like an advert — but they really do seem to have it figured out.
Gail says
Hi Kevin,
I recently replaced my front loader with another. They do use less water and detergent and are gentle on your clothes. With my new front loader I bought the pedestal to put it on which brings the door up to a comfortable height (and costs extra). I also got a larger capacity which will handle any size load. Good luck!
Linda says
So many comments, you probably don’t need another one, but here goes:
A few years ago I bought my first HE washer/dryer. After reading so many negative reviews on front loading (for all the reasons mentioned here), I decided to get a top loading washer, although the temptation to get the front model and put a counter across the top was strong). I love the new washer! All the high energy features of newer washers are wonderful. Without the agitator your washer feels so much bigger. But be careful not to just load it up to the top because it senses the weight of your load (that’s how it adjusts the amount of water to add) and the clothes get too packed to move around and wash properly. Your load will also run a very long time (hour and a half) and get out of balanced. I know because my energy saving husband thought he could do less loads by packing it to the top. Unfortunately, the clothes didn’t clean properly. My washer is a Kenmore Elite and it allows me to soak a load, time a load and many other choices and functions. Dryer has many choices also. The reason the clothes pack against the side of the drum is because the washer spins so rapidly and that’s how it presses out the water. It is not a big deal. Take a towel out and shake it out a little before putting in the dryer.
Sheila says
Try cutting back on amount on vinegar. My family has used it for generations instead of fabric softener-it takes out the soap-and doesn’t leave an odor
Unless I use too much.
Cindy says
Try opening the drain after every wash. You’ll likely have to catch the water in a pail. Our LG stunk so much you could smell it as soon as you came in the house & it didn’t matter how often I wiped seal dry, left door open etc. There are 2 cups of water left after every load that doesn’t spin out & that’s what was causing the smell. Still hate the machine – but at least my house doesn’t stink any more
Mare says
Front load. Cleaner clothes, less water. As for the issue of mold, I leave the soap drawer and door open after washing so it dries out. Never have any problem going on 4 years. I have Whirlpool and love it. Oh, I checked energy efficiency rating before purchase on EPA website since models differ. Takes longer to finish..50 minutes or so. Spin works so well drying time is reduced. Very happy…ordered-on-line through Costco. Delivered and set up inclded in price. Enjoy
Karen says
Many years ago we asked a appliance repairman what washer required the least amount of repair. Front loading washers, that was almost 40 years ago and have never bought anything else. They last forever.
Gina "I'm Italian, so cooking is in my blood" says
Do ANYTHING you can to hold on to your old washer. I’m not kidding. Your clothes will never truly be clean again if you “upgrade”….I would pay anything to get my old one back. For.so.many.reasons…..
Chris Thiessen says
I recently purchased a Kenmore Elite W/D top loading set after 28 years with another Kenmore. See through top and I LOVE it. No front loaders for me. I have seen too much!
Jeri says
I agree with George, who posted earlier in this this thread. I have a front loader and I wouldn’t have anything else. He’s correct that brand is everything; I’ve not experienced any of the mold issues others have expressed having, and it seems to me that my clothes are not only cleaner, but rinsed more thoroughly ( important for those of us with skin sensitive to most detergents and softeners)
Good luck in your search!
Helga G says
I am still using my 30 plus year old Kenmore top loader with matching gas dryer and love them. Only repair so far where new gaskets on both machines and one of the dials “popped off” the washing machine about 15 years ago. A little dab of Super Glue fixed it. So far so good.
Mare says
Ah, the bending over issue…I purchased the underneath drawer. Raises it up to perfect level. (We thought about the aging in place issues).
Reinette says
Get a top loader.
Never want to set eyes on a front loader again.
They are not worth the aggravation.
Love your posts!
C Miller says
I am happy to see some one pointed out that you could change the load size with needle nose pliers.
I have the exact same machine you presently have. I had a spring break on my tub. Went machine shopping and had decided on a LG top loader, my husband decided maybe he should look at my machine. Needless to say I really wanted that new machine, but I am still using the old one.
Strange how he has time to fix things after I go shopping for a new one!
I use a front loader at work, and hate it. I always prop the door open so it won’t smell, but others close it and, well you know.
Patti White Hansen says
Like you I own a 20+ year old washer and dryer. Though I haven’t purchased one yet, I am leaning toward a front loader:
1. A front loader has been rated to use so much less water than a top loader.
2. If the new washer AND dryer are both front loading a great work surface can be placed over the top of both to provide a place to fold OR to have the dual function of work surface AND to camouflage the machines in situations where the laundry is hidden away with a granite or other decorative as well as functional surface.
3. I believe the mold issue in front loaders is brand specific so homework will have to be done to find most efficient non mold front loader.
4. Stack-ability may be a nice option to have.
Still waiting for my washer to cease functioning but the front loader has appealed to me for these reasons. Happy hunting!
Aviatik says
I had a Frigidaire front load washer for 14 years and I replaced it when I moved. It was a small model but there were only two of us so it worked. It never smelled but I left the door ajar after each load and I also used bleach in the white loads. When it died I replaced it with an LG full size about 2 years ago and I love it. I also have had no problem with it smelling although I don’t use chlorine bleach in my white wash any more. I have also run a tub clean cycle a couple of times on it. It has a catch on the door that allows it to stay open a crack and I also leave the soap dispenser open. This LG has a separate rinse and spin cycle. It has a little door at the bottom you can clean out the filter through. I am able to stop my washer after it is going (the door unlocks) and add an item if it is necessary. I also love the flat top where I can fold all my clothes as I take them out of the dryer. I am very happy with a front loading washer and I would replace it with another if ever needed after doing extensive research on brand quality.
Judy Watson says
I have a newer (4 years old) front loading high efficiency washer and deeply regret our decision to buy it. It leaks – not much, but enough that I have to put a small pan under the door every time I use it, it doesn’t hold a lot and you need to leave the door open when not in use or it smells musty. I will never have another front loading washing machine.
SB says
Top load LG brand is best for washer, front load for dryer LG brand, trouble free brand with great warranty, no Samsung…just my opinion based on my experience
Patt Reid says
In our tiny house, we needed stackables. And I wanted full sized loads as well. We chose an LG model and I love it. I even use my homemade laundry detergent in it, and it cleans fantastically. We have a black dog that sheds aggressively, yet no problem with her hairs collecting in the washer or dryer. We’ve had them about 10 years, and I’d buy the same ones in a heartbeat.
Linda Pekrul says
I’ve been reading all the comments, and good luck to you Kevin… LOL…there is a huge variety of opinion!
I’ll add mine to the mix… after many, many years of using top loaders, I started using front loaders about 10 years ago…mainly because of their low water usage. During that time, we were moving a lot and left the appliances with the houses when we sold them, so I was able to try a couple different makes. The first one I had was a Whirlpool and I hated it because of the mold smell that everyone has been describing.
A couple of years ago, we splurged and got an LG True Steam front loading set and I have loved doing laundry ever since. (We did put them on the pedestals because I’m older now and bending down to reach the laundry was getting difficult.) I really appreciated the set when my asthma worsened… I can now throw pillows, etc into the dryer on the Steam Sanitary setting and they come out smelling fresh and clean and fluffy.
As for all the comments about not being able to pre-soak your clothes anymore… these machines have so many custom settings, including pre-wash, that it is mind boggling… you can set them according to what type of clothing you are cleaning and let them do their magic. My clothes are always clean and not wrinkled. I also like the feature on the dryer, where you can just freshen up your outfit with steam… sometimes that’s all they need and it saves a lot on drycleaning bills.
If you have big loads like we do with lots of dog blankets and towels, then make sure you purchase a large capacity model and you will not have any problems washing them. Someone else mentioned reading the manual carefully… and that is true… because these wonders can do everything but bake a cake! 🙂
I have had zero problems with mold smell. I do as others have stated… I always leave the door open to air dry, and dry the rubber gasket with a towel. One other whimsical feature I love for no other reason than it’s fun… it sings to me when it’s done… a few little notes that bring me running to it with a smile on my face! 😉 Good luck with your decision!
Ellie B says
After about 30 years of a Maytag, we bought a fancy Electrolux front loader and matching dryer. I have them stacked which gave me room for a cabinet in the laundry room. I’m short so I have a little stool for any situations. I do love this combo. It is HE and I agree that the cycles are long but I have a 15-min wash and dry on mine which I do use. I am home a lot and just plan on the time while I’m doing other things. The time goes by fast. This model has stain-soak and steam. The delivery man told me to keep the washer door open and to wipe down the gasket or it could start smelling. I have done that faithfully and I have no problem. I can wash all my comforters now (it is really large) and I do less loads because I can combine them. I can also stop pause the machine to add another item. I’ve had the combo since July 2016 so I feel comfortable rating it. I love this machine. It is also a shiny easy-care granite color, which looks awesome! Just my take, Kevin. It’s my first front loader and I hope it will do well for us for a long time.
Patricia Lapp says
I purchased an HE top loader, with high hopes for a lovely laundry room. The wash frequently came out in the same condition it went in. A special cleaner had to be added monthly to avoid mildew and the accompanying smell. Three days after the warranty was up the electronics went and the manufacturer couldn’t figure it out. I bought an inexpensive top loader with agitator and it does the job the Cabriolet didn’t. In doing further research a Speed Queen is highly recommended and has a 10 year warranty. I’ll take work horse over pretty any day.
Hannah says
There are HE top loaders that are energy efficient and use little water. Don’t need a front loader for that.
I had to replace my top loader maytag after 33 years and bought another top loader. I ended up with the simplest possible GE. Its generous size holds king size sheets and pillowcases in one load, or quilts and blankets. it has a speedwash cycle, a good thing sometimes because the other options take quite a long time although they do clean better. The presoak option helps, too.
Mari says
I like to add clothes with light wear later in the cycle…so I have a top loader (older model).
Maggie says
I’m still using a very old washer that will need replaced in the not too distant future. So I’m on the listening end of that part of this conversation. I noticed mention of mildew and less than pleasant smells and thought I’d opt in on that part. I keep a small spray bottle of water with about 20 drops of essential oils blended to spray the acupucturists office for viruses and colds brought in by patients (he uses an infuser). Amazing how just 1 short spray of this stuff will drift into every crevice once the lid is closed, taking away any mold or smell and it stays gone a long time. Hope that helps someone.
Mary Lou says
Have to admit that I didn’t read all of the previous comments. Quite a few of them. Just recently purchased maytag bravos top loader and dryer. My clothes are cleaner than before. I love the sensor option on the dryer. No more overcooked clothes. Additionally there is a product called afresh, that is recommended to run in the washer every 30 uses. Our set is so new, I haven’t used that product yet. Perhaps that is something that should be used in the front loader to address the odor issue. I will agree with the comment regarding losing space to fold clothes, store laundry soaps. I didn’t realize that the top of my new dryer had a sleek curve to it. So, pay attention to that – it’s just not with the washer.
Jean says
I would go with a top loader, but check out the various brands. I have a front loader. Issued with mold smell unless the door is left open to dry. Tried vinegar, bleach, etc. etc. nothing worked. Cannot just spin out with it if the clothes are left in a tangle and don’t spin out well; have to rinse and spin. I am sure all brands are different, but my mom bought a HE top loader and it is wonderful! Good luck Kevin.
Judy says
Hi Kevin wow loads of thoughtful words. Last summer I found myself wanting a new washer. So the research started. Everybody has good and bad to say about all of it. The issue most reoccurring in front end loaders is to make sure you leave the door cracked open to dry out other wise you get ugh mold. And if you live on a farm maybe a mouse. Also and this is very important what are the insides around the drum made of , steel or plastic? You want steel. Plastic is problematic.
I ended up planning to buy a Speedqueen. They come in top loading and front loading and they are ALL STEEL. In NC they run around 2000.00, but you have it for 20 some years. You also may warm to look up warming drawers to dry you clothes. Less on the electric bill.
We are moving to St. Croix VI to spend the last 30or 40 years in the sushine.
Love your articles!
Mary says
I say stick with what you know! Too many issues with front loaders and top loaders with no aggitators. Wiping down door gaskets is for people with nothing else to do except wipe down gaskets! Get a traditional Maytag and be set for many years! You can beat the heck out of them!
Kim Russell says
I fell in love with the front loaders because they look so sharp! Bought a beautiful pair by Frigidaire and after a short time came to hate the front load washer with a passion. It smells awful. Had to use a preparation called Smelly Washer Cleaner very frequently, this worked somewhat but I was never happy. Worst of all, after 3 years it broke. When the serviceman took it apart to see if it was reparable, I was shocked at the tiny spindle the whole thing spun on, at the rear of the drum. Of course it would break after a short time, it was rubbish. The dryer is fine, still going strong, but I replaced the washer with a top loader and I’ve never loooked back. So much for looks!!
Janis says
I agree with the Silver Fox… get the machine you like.
I have two homes, thus two washers. In the Forida home the machine is a medium-priced top loader. Works great. Gets clothes clean. In the California home the washer is a front loader… old one. Works great. Gets clothes clean. Bottom line, get the machine you like.
Lynne F. says
Kevin,
I stopped reading the comments here because of the negativity of some of them.
That said, I’m on my SECOND front loader (my first one is STILL working since 2005 in a rental house); I’d never have another top loader, EVER! Here’s why: The efficiency alone and the fact that you only use HALF the usual detergent is one saving; the “smells” coming from the tub are from NOT following the manufacturer’s recommendation to clean the tub MONTHLY with Tide Machine Cleaner. My new front loader was delivered one year ago (we moved to Florida), and came with a 10-year warranty provided you following the recommended usage and cleaning schedule.
In a front loader, queen/king size bedding, including mattress pads, are able to be laundered at home eliminating the need for the monthly “laundromat” expense and time.
I LOVE my front loader (both washer & dryer); the only thing I did wrong this time was NOT order the pedestals they sit on for extra money. My Connecticut washer has the pedestals, in which you’re able to store things like laundry supplies, light bulbs, odds and ends you’d usually relegate to a “junk drawer or closet” . . . the list is endless as to why I’d never have a top loader again, neither washer nor dryer!
Hope this helps you make a decision.
Sheena says
I agree with Tammy above. I’ve had a front loader (Kenmore) for 10 years. Love it. Clearly more efficient than my old top loader. Really quiet (I have an upstairs laundry closet.) Never a mold problem or a smell. Washes beautifully. I don’t have kids in the house anymore, so I suppose if I did I might have more issues re more and bigger loads, but I’d still go with front loading.
Rose says
Kevin,
I absolutely LOVE my traditional Speed-Queen top loading machine!!! it has a heavy-duty transmission, and a higher RPM on the spin cycle. The cycles on the water saving front loaders are way too long in my humble opinion. (We looked at them). I alternate dryer loads and hanging loads and can get through laundry very quickly. They are old technology that works (kind of like a land line!!). Our clothes always come out looking clean!
Janis says
And by the way… my sister just purchased a new washer. After gone thru all the hype, she decided on a Speed Queen and claims it is the best washer ever.
Jenn says
I just replaced my 20 year old, basic top loader and dryer with new high efficiency GE top loaders. I scoured reviews and these scored well. I wanted a large capacity washer so that I could throw my king sized down comforters in (with 3 dogs who sleep on the bed, they need to be washed often and dry cleaning them gets expensive).
I love the large capacity but without an agitator in the middle, the dog hair from my three pups remains on the clothes. I’ve tried liquid fabric softener, dryer sheets, and felt dryer balls and using the “deep fill” option (which means it isn’t high efficiency anymore. None of these work to get rid of the dog hair, which my old basic machines sucked right off the clothing.
I’m considering selling them on Craigslist and getting an agitator model. I can’t wear any of my dark clothing unless I spend 10 minutes or more with the lint brush. It’s frustrating. Your experience may differ with Lily the beagle- I have a very fluffy Alaskan Eskimo dog, so she sheds volumes.
I do love being able to do huge loads though, and they handle even my super puffy winter down comforter with ease.
Marianne Zimberg says
Love my LG top loader! Lots of choices in settings; delicate takes long cannuse “wool” setting for delicates too. Front loaders get the mildew odor, some brands have history of catching fire (see internet). Good luck.
Melodie says
Hi Kevin,
I have a Miele front load washer that is 13 years old. I bought it for environmental reasons, better cleaning and I was planning to use cloth diapers for my new baby. This machine has washed cloth diapers for two kids – I’ve still got the diapers and use them for rags and such – there is barely a stain on them and they have never been bleached. I don’t know about other front load machines but my Miele heats water to 180 F and has a spin that will go up to 1600 rpm. The hot water combined with Persil laundry soap always did an awesome job on the diapers. And my machine has never smelled, despite what I was washing in there:)
I love my Miele but we had some issues when we moved to this house. Our first laundry room was in the basement and the machine sat on a concrete floor – it never moved and we never heard it. Now we have a main floor laundry room and when the Miele went into spin mode, the whole house shook and it sounded like a helicopter was about to land on the roof. We addressed this with bracing in the floor joists beneath the machine, plus adding a 3/4″ sheet of plywood under the washer and dryer. If the load wasn’t balanced though, the machine walked a bit. We added a rubber stall mat from Tractor Supply (goat size and inexpensive) and now the machine stays put when the load isn’t balanced (plush towels are usually the problem). My laundry does get wadded up and I do have to stoop to load, but I don’t mind that. My machine is European size, so it has a smaller capacity then what North American’s are used to, but it looks very sleek under the counter. A normal wash takes 1 h, 40 minutes, a rapid wash is 40 minutes. I’m doing laundry for a family of four, and I have no complaints about the size of a load, or the time it takes to complete. I’ve had to service the machine twice – and I get a Miele tech to come. We don’t have a local tech, so usually my appointment ends up being the following week, but in both cases I could still use my machine and it wasn’t a big inconvenience. Overall, I have been very happy with my Miele. Whatever machine you decide on, consider giving Persil detergent a try. I buy the original German powdered soap, from Amazon. It’s expensive, but I use less then the suggested amount. It goes a long way, keeps our laundry very clean, and doesn’t knock you off your feet with the heavy smell of most other detergents.
I enjoy your posts. I’m getting ready to try winter-sowing my cool season vegetables and annual seeds, with the added twist of using my soil blocker to make transplanting easier. We’ll see how it goes.
Diane Hoik says
I dislike my new fancy dancy front loader. They’re not what they’re cracked up to be! I’ll never buy another one. Back to top loaders I’ll go. The front loaders smell and get nasty dirty. You have to use a special cleaner (an added expense)in them at least once a month, and wipe around the rubber door gaskets at the same time, which gets gross with muck, and is difficult to do – almost impossible to do thoroughly (and I’m a cleanliness nut). I can’t wait for mine to calve so I can get a top loader again, as fast as I can. I don’t see that the clothes get any cleaner in the front loader at all. You can get a high efficiency top loader. That’s my educated opinion: I’m a trained home economist.
Polly says
Hi Kevin,
I have had a Miele front loader for the past 5 years with absolutely no problems. We were lucky enough to be buying both the washer and dryer during a Miele 10 year warranty period also. I do run a vinegar wash every month and have never had any mold smell or problem.
Hope this helps in your decision.
marsha says
After having a top loader my entire adult life, I bought a front loader 10 yrs ag0. I have been cursing it ever since. It tangles clothes to the point of stretching to no return. If you put it on delicate, the clothes come out soaking wet. It is VERY loud on the spin cycle, it sounds like a jet landing.
I want this machine to break so badly! It claims to use less water but then the clothes feel like the soap isn’t completely washed out, you know that feel, so the extra rinse cycle is permanently on. One thing I have never had a problem with is mold. I leave the door open for about an hour after my final load of the day and that dries any remaining water on the door and seal. Finally, you almost HAVE to purchase the drawer that goes underneath unless you are 3′ tall. And when they are raised up to where you can comfortably load and unload, you can’t use the top for folding because it’s too high.
I would never recommend a front loader to any of my friends.
Branka says
I see you got tons of recommendations already but let me put my two cents in.
About 30 years ago my daughter was in a boarding school in Switzerland and she called me up and said “mom they have these amazing washing machines here and they wash your clothes like no ones business, you need to get one”. They were Miele. Of course no one here even heard of front load washers. I searched everywhere and finally found an appliance that ordered me one direct from Germany, a Miele. It took a while to get and the plumber was cursing the entire time he installed it because it was all metric. Kevin the first load l did was my bedding and when it came out the clothes actually smelled clean. It was simply amazing, and l was hooked.
About ten years ago my dryer quit so l went back to purchase another dryer but ended up buying the American made Miele dryer with accompanying front loading washer. It was big but l wanted a matching set so that was the main reason l bought the washer. Now l have two Miele front loaders and l love them both. The smaller German one is still going strong and if l have bigger loads l use the American made one.
Common sense needs to prevail, and after you use it you need to leave the door open a bit to dry it out. Kevin it’s the only way to go, and they have a boil wash cycle so it sanitizes as well.
I hope with all the space you have a clothesline. Come on go for it. we’ll make a house frau out of you yet!
Maggie says
I am sure you have read comments on both kinds of washer & dryers . In my PA condo, space is an issue and my Maytag front loader with the dryer on top does a great job and allows room for shelves etc in the area. The stooping a bit to unload clothes isn’t really an issue and I choose to go with that rather than have high shelves I couldn’t reach. Washer uses less water and does well with low suds HE detergent . My daughter has a top loading Bosch and come on , does anyone really need all those settings ?? Just go out & do it , though a look through Consumer Reports isn’t a bad idea.
Hilary says
When we got married, we inherited am old Maytag set, which lasted another 10 years! Now the washers and dryers only last around eight years! The first time you wash a load in a top loader you won’t believe how clean they get! I’m on my second set and would probably buy them again. Do leave the door and detergent cup open so you won’t get mold issues, and don’t skimp on a less expensive model. Good luck!
Mary S says
Having had both types, I would go with the top loader. I also would choose a Whirlpool, GE, Amana or Maytag. One of the problems with other brands, is that repair parts are not readily available and may be discontinued on relatively new models. Just a word of warning, since the newer washing machines have all sorts of sensors, do not put too much soap in them Had a LG (purchased in 2011) that would take over an hour to complete a regular cycle. Since I moved and inherited and older top-loader with the new home, definitely prefer fewer bells and whistles. Also use wool dryer balls, only I made my own – easy and very therapeutic to roll balls of yarn. Good luck with your search.
Sharon A. Shade says
In my new house I bought a front loader for energy efficiency. I despise it. The mildew that accumulates in the machine is a regular thing. I treat it by running an empty cycle with baking soda and bleach. The front loaders require you to clean the stripping around the opening on a regular basis and it’s a PITA. Go with a good top loader.
S says
Hey Kevin,
I had the same washer as you did (inherited it when we bought the house)and about 3 weeks ago when it went into the spin cycle it started making the most horrible noise, so we had the repairman out and he said the clutch was going and probably the transmission as well, also they aren’t making the timer for that model after next year so… I got a Speed Queen. I see a few comment about it above. I am from Wisconsin originally and lived near where they make Speed Queen. They are terrific machines, as someone said, built like a tank, 25 year warranty, stainless tub and dryer inserts, I got the top loaders as I have heard of the many mold issues, and my sister has one and says it always stinks, so no thanks. The speed queen uses more water than HE but I also think more water equals cleaner clothes. Also they are commercial grade for residential so the tub holds bigger loads than my old Whirlpool did. Very happy with my purchase.
Rachel says
Hi Kevin, so glad you asked this question! I highly recommend a top loader. We had a front loader (GE, pretty expensive) for 3 years. Had issues ALL THE TIME! Luckily, we bought the extended warranty because we had to call for fixes at least 5 times. Front loader uses little water, the clothes often smelled musty or just not clean after washing. When we decided to get a top loader, my husband destroyed the front loader Office Space style.
Our Samsung top loader is HUGE! It hold a ton of wash. It allows you to soak whites in bleach if needed. Clothes are clean, no smell. Love it.
Will never go back to front loade again, never.
Marilyn Elliott says
Front loaders were all the rage for awhile but I now hear growing dissatisfaction with them. I have a top loading Maytag that I’ve had for many, many years and I love it. I’ve never had any trouble with it, as in no repairs needed. My only complaint is that it’s not large enough to wash a queen size comforter, which is why I advise getting the largest tub available.
Joanie says
Good Morning, Kevin!
The answer is in what you need for your individual lifestyle. As a gardener, a dog owner, and a family of two, I find my extra-large capacity, HE top loader much more practical than a front loader. I sometimes like to pre-soak clothes after a day out hiking or gardening in the dirt/mud and that’s where the top loader shines. It’s also easy to pop in a couple of extra items after the cycle starts. I have no problem washing my queen size bedding, even a comforter, in the xl capacity machine – something I couldn’t do with my old washer. I’m also a procrastinator so a last-minute quick wash of a few items is something I find myself doing quite a bit – on my machine that is a 38 minute wash that does the job brilliantly. As others mentioned, top loaders also do a much better job with delicates and varying sizes of loads.
For a large family doing constant giant loads of washing, I can understand the appeal of the front loader. For one or two people who do different size loads, I think a top loader is more customizable.
Keep in mind that the newer appliances overall are not made to last decades. I bought a new fridge two years ago and every salesperson at every store I explored told me that new computer-driven appliances have a shelf life of maybe 10 years. (My old fridge was 21 when it died.) The same goes for washers.
Let us know what you end up with!
nancy dickson says
Top Loader!! One reason only – I often find, just as the wash cycle starts, that I have one other thing to add. You can open a top loader and drop it in, you can’t open a front loader.
Renee Coursey says
Good luck with whichever you buy. I have had both top and front loader washers. I have had a problem with the smell too but the service man told me to use HE Tide powder and not to use the liquid soap or the little pods. He said they both have animal fat in them which is part of the smell problem. Also he said to use No More than 1 TBLS. of the powder. I have done this every since I found out and the smell is pretty much gone now. It has to do with the rubber gasket on the front of the machine which is quite large. Drying that out with a towel and keeping the door open slightly and the soap drawer open has done away with the smell. Mine does use a lot less water which I like because of conservation. They have some really pretty colors now too!
SL in Saratoga says
You have a lot to read Kevin! I have had HE front loaders for 15 years. First set were LG. I would get residue on my clothes from the washing machine. Yuk! Changed to Maytag HE front loaders. Love both washer and dryer! High spin speed in washer means shorter dry time in dryer. To avoid odors, leave the door of the washer ajar, as recommended in your owner’s manual. Wipe rubber ring with a clean cloth. Use “Afresh” or other machine cleaner at minimum once a month. I use a water softener and use less soap. I use machine cleaner about every 3 months. I NEVER have an odor in my machines. Wash day is so easy!
Jayne says
Bought a front loader 8-10 years ago. Loved the look – grew to hate the machine. It gets gross and moldy around the rubber gasket and now matter how much I try and clean it, it never gets as clean as I would like it. I’m hoping it dies out on my soon so I can go back to a top loader.
Jamie, Sacramento, CA says
This company http://www.appliancepartspros.com/
has always had any part I needed for my washer or dryer. Including replacement knobs. They have great customer service and the part arrives very quickly. All they need is the make and model number. Give them a call.
Once upon a time a fancy HE (high efficiency) Samsung top loader with an all computerized selection panel came into my life and I thought I would give it a try, because my trusty Maytag with a simple set of knobs where I could choose the water level and load size, and that worked JUST FINE, was old, right?
Well! I couldn’t get rid of that Samsung fast enough. What a nightmare. There was no way to manually control the water level, to start with. It took FOREVER to do a cycle, and here’s the news. A full load of clothes DOES NOT get clean in four inches of water. I don’t care what anyone says. There was no way I could manually control the water level. I had to take the water level that the possessed Samsung decided to trickle out and I ended up filling the tub with a bucket. By the end of the day I wanted to take a pick ax to it.
Thank goodness my Maytag was still sitting in the garage waiting to be returned to its rightful place in the world. I’m lucky it hadn’t decided to pick up and go live at someone else’s house just out of spite.
That Maytag has run nearly flawlessly for 29 years, and if I ever have to replace it, I will try to find the most rudimentary KNOB controlled washer I can find, because knobs do not have an electronic computerized control panel that needs to replaced and that can drive one mad just trying to do the simple task of doing a load of wash. It’s clothing folks, not the dead sea scrolls. Just add water and detergent, and let ‘er rip.
LD says
I have an LG Tromm front loader about 10 years old. It broke a couple of months ago and I was going to get a new top loader. Well….I fixed my old machine and very glad I did. The new top loaders, every person that bought one that I know hates them. And then there is the Samsung recall because they explode. I’ll keep my front loader. My last load is either a vinegar rinse for my gym clothes that cannot take fabric softener or my whites with chlorine bleach. I then dry out the gasket, since that is what gets bad and dry the door and leave open. That keeps the washer clean. Every couple of months if the kids are sloppy I do a bleach clean or use a washing machine cleaner to refresh. Good luck. Oh one more thing. I noticed the new top loaders have a 90 minute wash time!!! Crazy long. Mine is 60 minutes regular with a 30 minute quick cycle. Make sure to look at this before you buy.
Mary W says
HATE the new efficient low water machine we got about one year ago. WATER is needed to clean! You won’t find a nice new machine that will last as long as the old one since they are all made of plastic parts now. I do have advice – NOT a front loader. My son got the newest and best and within a year there was a problem and when it was opened, it flooded his hardwood floors which then had to be replaced. I would stick with the top loader every time. If there is a problem, you won’t ruin your floors! The old days, Maytag was a great but expensive kind that lasted 20 years easily. Now they are made in China and the same as any other so it is kind of like lawnmowers. Buy cheap as possible and throw it away before you have to store it for winter. Then get a new one next year since you will end up doing that anyway (cheaper to buy new than fix). Washers and dryers have turned into that kind of waste.
Rebecca says
We’ve had a Whirlpool Cabrio washer and dryer for several years now and I’d buy them again. The washer is a top loader with just an agitator bump at the bottom. I can get my king size comforter into the machine however, it is tight.
Sherlie Magaret says
I have a Maytag Neptune front loader matching washer and dryer and have had them for a long time, it uses as much water as needed for the amount of clothes, I use Mrs. Meyer’s laundry detergent so I use very little. Does have some mildew around the door gasket but it never smells nor has it ever. I do run two loads of whites per weeks with bleach and hot water and I am sure that keeps things clean. Usually run that load at the end of all my loads as I am one of those people that does all my laundry on one day. I don’t use fabric softener and I think that helps. Just checked and we purchased them in 2003, I know it was before they came out with pedestals. I am not going to say we have never had a problem because I don’t want to jinks them.
Susan says
Kevin, we also have a 20 year old top loader (Kenmore) that is going strong after replacing the solenoid value, a very inexpensive part. I’ll buy another when it dies primarily because I like to soak things. You can’t do that with a front loader. Energy-efficiency is important, but so are durability and flexibility. It’s said “They don’t build them like they used to” and our newer Kenmore dryer (2014) is a case in point. Clothes don’t dry well with that machine, and so I use clotheslines in the basement to finish the job.
Btw, I subscribed to Garden Design mag. What a joy.
LynneRoCo says
I have a Whirlpool Cabrio platinum 8900 top loader HE washer and I HATE IT!!! It’s about 3 years old now. First off, it leaves white filth on ALL of our dark clothes. First load, I took pictures and called the obnoxious place I bought it from, in an email. They said they never heard of this and that I must be doing something wrong. I did a search online and MANY people reported the same thing. So upset with myself, that I didn’t search this before buying. 2 more loads – same thing. The store wouldn’t take it back, saying they never heard of this and that I must be washing incorrectly!!! Called the company – they also said I must be washing wrong – UH NO! So then they told me to wash everything in hot water. UH NO! So we decided to dilute the ity bity amount of soap with lots more water each wash, and that seemed to do the trick. PITA! BUT… all that said, this washer does not get rid of stains that should easily come out. Nor slight typical smells. This washer stinks, plain and simple! AND, of course the following year this model was no longer available, and a new and improved one is for sale now. HATE THIS MACHINE! 😛 The p.s. to this… the matching dryer often does not dry a regular sized load on the normal setting. GARBAGE!
Maraya says
I bought a new front loading washer in 2011 after always having top loaders. Pros: No agitator – easier on clothes, less water. Cons: Have to leave it open to avoid mildew, lower water level does NOT remove pet hair very well, filter difficult to access, wash time 2-3 times as long.
DO NOT BUY SAMSUNG. That was a big mistake. If I had a do-over, I would probably buy LG. Also, try to get a good old fashioned porcelain finish if available. The finish on the top of my Samsung actually came off when I spilled a little detergent on it. Can you imagine – a washer that cannot tolerate a detergent spill?
I like the recommendation for an XL top loading LG, especially if you have pet hair to contend with. I really miss the old GE Filter-Flo machine! I also used to have a great Speed Queen with a stainless drum, but that was many years ago and I’m unfamiliar with their present quality.
To all of you who had mildew problems: Besides doing clean cycles and leaving the door open, there were a few recalls for this – I believe from Whirlpool and/or Samsung. Check it out.
Pat says
I love all the comments. Your readers do have wealth of knowledge. The only thing I would like to say is, if you do decide to buy a top load be sure that it has an agitator. Otherwise you will have a TANGLED mess of clothes for sure.
Diane says
I had Maytag Neptune front loader for years and loved it. When we moved in 2013 I figured it would be easier to start new. My son and daipughter-in-law chise an LG pair. Front load on this washer is straight up and down. Previous own made a shelf from a large door which fits over the laundry pair and makes a great space to store the laundry basket and detergent and lots of stuff. I am 68, and 5’2″. The machines sit on the floor so I use a “step” from my old step exercising days to sit on when switchng clotes from washer to dryer and when removing clothes from the dryer. Then I practicing standing up without using my hands. My outer thighs are stronger than ever and I feel it helps my balance. When I first saw the set-up I told my son it would keep me young or be the death of me! I love the machines and they do a good job. The Neptune was more intuitive as far as load choice, though. It had a ” stain cycle” which really worked.
I have looked at the new top loaders when walking past them at Lowe’s. Whoever designed those didn’t have any short women try them out. I absolutely cannot reach the bottom of the tub, even on a step stool!
Evelyn Harder says
Buy a SpeedQueen washing machine – you will not go wrong with them. Costs more. But not a disposible appliance in 5 yrs.
Anne Schmidt says
I have had only 3 washing machines in my 46 years of marriage – and only one husband! I like simple so I recommend staying with a top-loader. The two times we’ve had to get a repair, the repairman said to always get a machine with an agitator. The last machine we bought is a top-load, stainless steel tub with an agitator. It has all the bells and whistles we need – a GE model. Love it!
Patrick says
Kevin,
I have to agree with Terry above! We bought a new washer and dryer 7 months ago, a fancy Samsung HE top load washer and matching dryer. They suck! The low (Energy Saving) water during washes leaves white streaks of soap on dark clothes! We had a repairman come out and the first thing he told us was that he’s had 20 complaints about this issue and there’s nothing he could do to fix it and the company knows all about it!
We tried contacting the company and couldn’t get past their complaint desk somewhere overseas that would not have their supervisor return our calls. Don’t waste your time or money Kevin!
j fleming says
I’ve know a few folks who have bought front load machines and every single one hates them. I always go top load. As I get older, the last thing I want to do is to have to bend over to stuff clothes into a washer.
Susan M. says
Wow, Kevin! You’ve got plenty of advice, but guess I’ll add my two cents. Three years ago I needed a new machine. I wanted the simplest mechanical (that is non-digital, easy to repair) machine with the best reputation for doing the best job cleaning clothes. My pick is never mentioned in a popular consumer reports magazine, but it’s manufactured right here in the US, and it’s been around and reliable (think laundromats) for a long time. I found the only outlet in my area – 30 miles away, but he delivered – and I ordered the old fashioned, top loading SPEED QUEEN. I love it!
Susan says
Addendum: The reason I mentioned the solenoid value is because you said your current machine is stuck on medium. If by that you mean the tub will only fill with water for a medium-sized load, an inexpensive solenoid value will fix that. On the other hand, a shiny new machine …
Linda Carlow says
Personally I like my front loader from the aspect of doing a better cleaning job. You need to keep rubber gasket clean along with glass on door.
I would stay away from Samsung, they are not a washing machine company.
I have a whirlpool and have used it for at least ten years. Prior to that I had a Maytag for 25 years, now owned by Whirlpool.
Sarabeth says
From the comments it seems that these people love the same type of washer that they first purchased 45 years ago! Top loaders! No way! Bought a front loader Fridgedaire and LOVE it. Uses 1/10th of the detergent, 1/2 the water and gets everything spotless. As for mold or smells – any time you leave wet clothes in a confined closed-door space you will get both be it top or front loader. That is called common sense.
My washer does tiny loads, and I can get queen-size bedroom items into it as well. It also has a “spin-dry” cycle on it as well that is useful. In fact – it has about 10 cycles and I have used every single one at one time or another! They do come in handy.
I always wipe the glass door dry after the last load and leave the door open for about 1 hour. Never had mold or smell issues. And as for them sitting low to the ground (though mine is a regular height) they sell accessory platforms to raise them up which I assume you know by now.
I am all for using and dumping less water into our environment. These front loaders really fit the bill. And the new HE detergent is much more environmentally friendly. The only caveat I would say is watch which brand you purchase. As in anything else – brands differ and some are better than others.
Bobbie Modesto says
If you get this far! Holy smokes you have your answer! 150 times over but here’s your 151st one.
I have had 3 front loaders over 10+ yrs. It’s just my silver fox and I now but still bought the biggest drum as you’ll need for duvets etc. FYI Samsung They were bad for the smell but have improved 100% over time. They do use less water and work well. I like them but it just preference. Unless u want to stack them which I have done and is a great idea for small areas. Good luck.
Debbie says
Maytag Bravo’s XL
BEST WASHER IVE EVER OWNED. (and I’ve owned a lot as I raised 6 kids). Top loading HE. You will LOVE it!
Ruth Hill says
Being a Brit living in Fl. – I replaced my top loader with a front loader. This gives me space to put a beautiful counter-top across the washer & dryer where I can fold clothes, prep meals for my pups, fill my bird feeders, mess with my indoor plants etc, etc. 🙂 I always leave the door to the washer “ajar”to avoid mold & smells. Your machine will tell you when to clean it & I do so when the light flashes. There is less wear & tear on clothes as there isn’t an agitator. I wouldn’t change my system for the world, it suits me. I do not know anyone in the UK with a top loader, in fact – I don’t know you can even buy them there anymore.
Susan Iseman says
Kevin:We have Bosch front loaders- they may or may not still be made here. Find your best appliance store and do your research. A couple of things:
1. We initially set them up side by side, and eventually stacked them to rearrange the room they were in. Stacking requires a “stacking kit” which we were luck to find and have installed. If not stacking, they sometimes sell a base to mount them- raises them up and saves stooping over so low- killing your back.
2. True, the newer models are more efficient- as such, they require less detergent- very important as this is the main reason for problems-so pay heed to that rule.
3. My dryer features a wrinkle relax/steam/refresh option- a miracle to remove wrinkles from clothing and freshen them- saving from the horrors of dry cleaning. Sweaters, cotton- even my husband throws in his dress pants. A FABULOUS FEATURE. Good luck!
PS: Watch for President Day sales….
GOod luc
Laura says
We were in the same spot about 7 years ago and decided to go with the front loader. Sadly, we had to retire our top loader Kenmore that served us well for almost 20 years (and we had bought it used!). Were were between the Speed Queen top loader and the Electrolux front loader. Like other have said, the Speed Queens are solid, reliable performers. We were told many businesses (laundromats, group homes etc.)buy them because they are built so well and can take heavy duty usage. We chose the Electrolux front loader because we are on a well and need to conserve water and wanted to have shorter drying times. We also liked the reputation of the Miele but we were concerned about the availability of service repair professionals in our area if we needed one. Right away, we noticed how much dryer the clothes came out of the spin cycle, and subsequently how quickly they could come out of the dryer. Dryers use so much electricity! We have never had problems with mold or smells. We use very little detergent (less than marked on the washing machine fill cup) and we leave the door open when not in use. Our machine has a “sanitize” cycle, which I would say should be a requirement. It is great for towels, as they are most at risk for having a sour smell, and ours never do after this cycle (using very small amount of detergent is important here). Make sure your machine also has an “extra rinse” option and a “spin only” cycle, which have been handy. While I don’t believe it will last as long as our previous washing machine, we have been happier than expected with its performance thus far. Good luck!
Peggy says
A few years ago an appliance salesman told my sister he would sell her whatever she liked but he strongly recommended a Speed Queen top loader. That is what she bought and loves it. So, naturally, when I needed a new washer & dryer, I bought Speed Queen commercial heavy duty.
My husband doesn’t even mind doing laundry now. We love it!
Ginger says
I have a front load – and never again! I too crack the door and dry out the dispenser – but I have an atrocious odor from the machine on every first load I do. And, my towels have the same odor about them (I do my towels last, but do not use fabric softener – to keep them thirsty). Rest of clothes smell OK – but I use several sheets of fabric softener with each load. Several of the people I work with have the same issue with their front-loaders. I’ve even used the washing machine cleaner you can purchase, but this means running the machine by itself (wasting water and electricity) and the odor is still present, although in a lesser amount.
I never had any issue with my top-loading machine.
nannyjt says
actually, front loader machines do not use as much water/detergent and the spin is a lot more rigorous so if you want to save on water/etc. front loaders are better
lise says
KEVIN, check the reviews from Consumer Reports! i did, and never had a problem.
we have a kenmore bottom loader, it lasted for a VERY long time! we had never any problems one day we had to replace it,It just wore down. and then we have a 2nd one from kenmore. it’s bottom loader, it’s lasted for 7 yrs now, no problems , i add the softener if i choose, my Oxy clean for my uniforms, and my whites have always come out very clean. I love the way the settings are, and would not have a top loader unless i had very little room. There that’s what i think, the bottom line is the bottom loaders i think clean better. But it’s the Kenmore!!!!
Mary Anne Cella says
I have a Samsung front loader. I think it is fine. FYI–you can make your own dryer balls. Buy some 100% wool yarn. If you can find some thickish wool, it is better. Roll up into balls about the size of a tennis ball. Catch the tail with a needle. Put them–you can probably get 3 out of a skein of yarn or , if you buy fisherman wool maybe as many as 6–in a stocking and throw them in with your wash and then in the dryer. Do this 3 or 4 times and then remove from the stocking. Add all of them to your dryer. They make clothes dry faster and you don’t need a dryer sheet. I have at least 6 in my dryer at all times.
Bev says
Bought a fancy new front loader 15 years ago – hated it. Didn’t clean my clothes as well and EVERYTHING got tangled! Moved and inherited a 15 year old Whirlpool top loader. Love it. Whew. Clothes are noticeably cleaner, it holds more and no tangles. I’ll never have a front loader again!
Jean says
My daughter has had two front loaders due to space limitations. Yes, they are smelly and the door must be left open. A small towel over the door usually prevents it from being closed by neatniks. Her bath towels always seem to have a sour smell. I have an old top loader Whirlpool and have loved it for years! I don’t think I could live without the gentle cycle that washes wool sweaters beautifully! If you forget to put something in the load, just open the lid and drop it in! This is not possible with a front loader. When they get really old as mine is, you occasionally must use the spin cycle twice (depending on the weight of the load).
Larry McChesney says
Well, after 150 odd replys, you’ve probably already made up your mind, but here’s my 2 cents worth, anyhow.
We purchased a new Asko washer and dryer set in 1987, right after we finished construction of our home. The washer lasted 20 years and we were offered another Asko, free at that point. We took it and we still have it, going fairly strong. The dryer is original and works like a champ. All these machines are front loader. They don’t tear up your clothes, they’re easy to work on, should anything need replacement, they use less water so they’re easy on the well, and they do a great job!
We had a little scare last year, when the washer began acting like it was giving up the ghost, so we bought a new and larger front loader, an LG, from Home Depot. Approx $800. Cheap, by front loader standards. All these front loaders can be stuffed full and they still get things clean and sanitary. As for mold, never had that problem.
Another item to consider is the front loaders have no transmission. Fewer parts to break and they spin like crazy. Less time in the dryer. We’ll never own another top loader. Best of luck!
Rae Fuller says
Be sure to get insurance on whatever machine you choose. They don’t make them like they used to. I have had both front and top loader machines and both did the job well. Best of luck!!
Robin Gauvreau says
Short sweet and to the point. We have a twenty year oldstacked w&d, standard, straight forward clean clothes. My daughters have the newer front loaders. Less water is used, but the cycle takes forever and there is no choice of load size – water level. We all love my old set. So much for progress.
Verilee says
you probably don’t need any more advice but I love my very basic front loader that I am able to stack with dryer. much less water usage, clothes not beat up by agitator and clothes nice and clean! good luck!
Jan Jacklin says
I wouldn’t have a front loader…too, too many issues my friends have had,,,repairs unbelievable…I have a top loader that has no agitator…so it is like a front loader without the problems & headaches (who needs those)…Have a great time shopping…I love my Maytag Top Loader…
Colleen says
I ran screaming (literally crying) from top loaders after having too many very good clothing pieces ruined. After way over 20 yrs my front loader gave out and I found through research that the newer models of any brand are not made to last like the previous ones. I now have a Whirlpool Duet (only the washer as the drier was just fine) which I bought from Costco since they would install and carry away the old one and were still cheaper. It has 12 cycles including a soak cycle and one for just cleaning the machine and the spin cycle is really strong. The technician told me that the “cold water soaps” are usually made with soy and will not completely clean out of the clothes with cold water. He also said to run vinegar in the washer clean cycle once a month which I seldom do. I have NEVER had mold in any of my machines, top or front loading, in the last 40 years and I’ve lived in damp, coastal Oregon and dry inner mountain areas. I do leave the door ajar on my front loader so the machine can dry and air out between loads. This machine has cleaned heavy-construction clothing, cowboy clothing (yup think the worst), fuel delivery clothing, and my delicates and done just fine. So fine in fact I no longer separate a hand wash pile. There are stands for front loaders if one needs them. I am short so I use a plastic spaghetti claw to get the small items out from the back of the drum.
Marsha S. says
Counting on you to sift thru all of this info and come out with the best!!
In skimming comments-did not see where anyone complained of the noise of a front loader-ours sounds like a jet engine getting ready to take off!
Have found our big Maine coon cat taking a nap in our front loader several times as I have to leave door open! so guess it is good for something-
myriam says
I am in my sixties and have lived here and in Europe; have ONLY had one top loader and all the other ones have been front loaders. I hated the top loader because the laundry did not come out as clean as in the front loaders.
BUT, I agree with the readers who write to either purchase a Miele or a Bosch. A friend of mine had an LG and she was so dissatisfied that she threw it out after six months. I have a new Bosch since a year and my previous Bosch was 18 when we replaced it.
I have never had mold in any of my machines. I must say that when I do not use it, I leave the door open – nobody comes in the laundry room anyway…
Hope that it helps taking a decision! Happy Laundry!
Mimi says
I bought a front load washer 8 years ago thinking I would save $$$ on my water bill. Nope. Didn’t save a cent! And that very long wash cycle was truly annoying.
I bought a new house that included an older model top loader and it works great. I’m not a fan of front loaders.
Joyce Van says
I’m still using WRINGER WASHERS !! Have had several different brands and have no preference. The current wringer washer is a Maytag again. I can adjust the temperature, the water level, the soak cycle length and the wash length. I have the galvanized rinse tub on legs and use vinegar in the rinse. My clothes are clean and it takes only a little more effort on my part to do laundry. I love WRINGER WASHERS !!!
Blue says
I’ve always had Maytag machines, so of course I purchased a new front load maytag in 2009I. Very bad choice! Mildew on door gasket that cannot be cleaned. Did not know that they had been bought out by Whirpool. What a shame.
LaVon Eblen says
Did you ever forget and leave a paper tissue in your pocket? In a top loader it will be in shreds scattered in all the clothes. Front load it comes out in one piece. Imagine the difference in what it does to your clothes. Front loader for me with all the environmental pluses. I have never had an odor/mold problem with my front loader.
Cathy says
I researched washers at length because I wanted a sturdy, simple top loader. I bought a large capacity Speed Queen online – they’re sturdy and often the washers that laundromats use. It works well, doesn’t eat clothes and doesn’t get moldy like front loaders do. Good luck!
Karen H. says
Hi Kevin,
Longtime fan of your blog, and first time commenting! I had a Whirlpool Duet front loading washer for 5 years, and then every other month I would get an error code indicating something wasn’t working, but luckily my husband could fix the problem. Even though I left the door open, wiped the gasket and cleaned it with bleach, I still had a musty odor. The odor was very noticeable, especially on my towels. I finally had enough of the error codes and researched washing machines. I purchased a Speed Queen top loading machine…it has an agitator and regular push and pull knobs. I can wash the same amount in the Speed Queen as I did in the Whirlpool Duet washer. I have had it several years now and absolutely love it!
Beth says
I had an old front load washer that I liked, but it needed to be replaced. I bought a Maytag front load and love it. This new machine is a lot faster and the clothes are very clean. I never had an odor issue in either machine. Some people say that you can’t soak in a front load, but in my old machine, I would push pause 5-7 minutes after it started, let it soak as long as I wanted it to, then start again. I have not tried that it my new machine yet, but it worked great in the old machine. We also bought the dryer to match, but didn’t want to pay for a pedestal, (I was able to use the old one for the washer) so my husband made one. Many different ideas on YouTube.
Lorraine J. says
Hi Cindy, my Whirlpool Duet used to have F20 errors. The manual said it was the suds sensor. It was indicating that there was a suds overflow – which requires one to drain and rinse the load before starting over. Maybe this us your problem?
Went online to look at the parts manual, bought a new sensor from a local repair shop and replaced it in back of the machine. Aside from having to take the machine’s back cover off, it was very easy to do. It’s never been a problem since and cost less than $40 Cdn.
sue says
I also have one of the new top loader hi efficiency machines. They hold a huge amount but I find the big tub hard to reach in to and most of all it destroys many of my towels & tablecloths hems.
Janice in Vermont says
I have never had any problem with my Frigidaire Energy Star front load washer and (gas) dryer, both brand new when I bought them over 13 years ago. Big loads, I can adjust cycle to suit the load, clothes are clean, and no mildew or guck issues even though I’ve never left the door open.
Previously I had only had top loading washers, and the only negative I’ve experienced is that once the cycle starts, you can’t stop a front loading washer to toss in that sock you dropped…
Not a big deal, considering that I now have a big counter over the machines instead of wasted space.
Lorraine J. says
Ha ha! I had to laugh at your jet engine comment. When I did machine research 10 years ago that was all anyone talked about. Mine makes that loud whine too but I figure the faster the spin, the louder the engine.
sue says
after reading more of the reader comments, I’m adding 2 more.
I response to the lady who has the Maine Coon taking naps inside. Be aware many cats have been killed this way when the machine is turned on inadvertently.
Also I would go back to my large capacity Kenmore top loader in a heartbeat. No more hi-efficiency’s. One can also purchase a cleaner for refreshing these machines near the laundry detergent.
Tina Root says
My Maytag, top-loader, is from the babyhood of my 31 year-old. It has had one repair, when mice chewed a wire. I dread replacing it, or even researching for replacing it. I’ll lean on you. But not for 20 more years.
Laura K says
I realize that there are numerous comments to this and what I have to say has probably already been said..
We also inherited a washing machine when we bought this house that looks IDENTICAL to the one that you have. That washing machine ate our towels & sheets, tore our clothes and I never felt like the machine was getting the clothes clean.
We bought the LG set and I couldn’t be happier. My towels went from grey back to brilliant white after one sanitize cycle. The new machine has not yet had that smell issue (it’s been 8 months) and it’s probably because I love white linens, I love bleach (hate me…it’s ok) and I love the sanitize cycle. This extra hot water + bleach is likely keeping the drum and inside the machine clean and so far smell free it’s also making my whites super bright. I can also fit so much laundry in these things that I have a hard time making up a full load. The machine also has a “clean drum” cycle but I haven’t had to use it yet.
These machines have every bell and whistle and I absolutely LOVE them. Since I replaced all the appliances in the house ( all of them I am sure were 20-30 years old) I have been saving 25-30% on my monthly power bill. I have not benefited from the same savings on my water bill and I haven’t been able to figure out why.
One vote for front loader – and a thumbs up for the LG brand.
Lynn Paterson says
I have a new set of front loaders and I find that the washer door must be left open at all times when not in use as it mildews up and stinks. If you have limited laundry room space that is a real problem, always walking into the open door !
Mary says
Top loader, absolutely. Here is a good article which recommends the front loader, but if you look at the downside, top loaders are better at least for the stray sock problem and loading and unloading. Good luck, Kevin. http://thesweethome.com/blog/should-you-get-a-front-or-top-load-washing-machine/
Kylee says
I used a top loader at a clients house many times. Sometimes the clothes on top if you had a big load came out of it dry so Probably they didn’t get washed. A front loader can be stuffed pretty full and mine rarely smell and I rarely leave the door open or use vinegar. A friend had one that did smell so I fixed the problem with a vinegar and water spray bottle and making sure any soggy lint was wiped from the seal
Fran Sheehan says
I do not like my front loader at all. I can’t soak clothes when needed. Have to use an alternate method for that. I will go back to a top loader soon. One with a large agitator like days of old!!
Some of the newer models have an agitator that is only a few inches high(my friend has one and doesn’t feel her clothes get as clean).
Good luck with your decision.
Donna Dean says
I have an HE top loader by Fisher and Paykel. I love it. It spins really well and the dryer is weird but works great. Happy shopping.
sandie says
I like the top loader because I can add more items if I wish once the washer has started. I can control the water and it fills while I am treating the clothes that need stain remover. I just find it is very flexible.
Front loaders look beautiful but from the little I know, once you put the clothes in, you can’t open the washer so you might have too much water or too little .
Kathy from Cold Climate Gardening says
If you get a front loader, make sure you have enough clearance in your laundry room to open the door all the way. Some laundry rooms (especially retrofitted into older homes) are very cramped. I know that is the reason we stick with top loaders. (By the way, I think you say front loader one time when you meant to say top-loader.)
Kip Morrissette says
My front loader washer got mold stain around the sealer and there was nothing to be done about it. It was actually a Stack-able Maytag Neptune, with Washer on bottom. You only have a certain amount of time to add something to a front loader should you forget to add something.
Finally the washer bit the dust, bless its heart, and I was happy and didn’t even call a Repairman that is how bad I didn’t like it. But, I didn’t want to lose the dryer as it is the best dryer I’ve ever had. I wasn’t sure what to do but we have an outstanding electrician friend who came and did ‘whatever’ to make the dryer work without the washer. My husband built a base with pull out shelves for storage, and set Dryer on top. This made the dryer eye level and makes it so easy on your back when unloading it.
OK, here is the BEST WASHER EVER: It is a top loader made by Fisher & Paykel Eco Smart. I wasn’t familiar with this brand but it was the only top loader that allowed me to be able to reach the bottom of tub which is important when you are not all that tall. It has wonderful features, one being that the lid locks once its started and a Start/Pause that allows you to unlock the lid and add more clothes right up to the time the load is finished. I find I can dry jeans and towels 30-40 minutes and other pieces in 30 minutes which I’ve never been able to do with any other washer as they didn’t remove enough water from the clothes.
Good Luck Kevin.
Judy says
I agree with the Speed Queen top loader. We love ours and are solidly built and built to last. We do two rinses on our wash and got the model that has that option.
Jody says
You have a lot to sift through, Kevin, so I’ll break it down for my pros & cons. I have an HE front loader washer & dryer, which I bought without thinking what I’d be losing after always having top loaders.
Pros of a top loader: can soak clothes for as long as you like…can add something anytime during the wash cycle…can stop & restart again if you want 2 wash cycles or 2 rinse cycles but don’t need the full wash/rinse cycle each time…you don’t have to worry about a cat crawling into the dryer and hiding among the clothes if you’ve opened the dryer door but can’t get the clothes out right away…can get the clothes out easier from a top loader instead of bending from the knees and stretching waaaay in to reach the back items stuck to the back of the drum.
Pros of a top loader: uses less water, is quieter, clothes come out of washer almost fully dry.
My sister agrees with me on all these points, but she recently went back to a top loader and was unaware that some of the newer ones don’t allow an unlimited soak time. Her machine turns back on after a 20 minute soak. It decides for her, ok–you’ve soaked your towels long enough.
kate says
I vote for top loader. Ours is going on 20 yrs old; we had the dryer drum adjusted and the repair person said these basic machines are the best. No computer boards. Tough as nails. Ours has the small to large setting for washing and still works fine.
Maureen says
Are you more confused now than ever? I only went through about 10 comments and my head is spinning. Sure glad I didn’t read those before we bought. We have the front loader, Whirlpool Duet, that has to be at least 10 years old. I really like how it cleans and seems to be gentle on the clothes. I can cram a lot of clothes in it. I especially like the soak and spin cycle. To keep it aired out (mold) I always leave the door ajar and also pull the little drawer for soap and softener slightly out when not using. Now for the bad…..the control board did have a problem, all over the internet you can read about the error code which shows up on the machine. Luckily we read about a place in North Carolina where you send the old board and they repair it. They say the board is better than the original or replacement from Whirlpool. Not sure, but that was probably about 5 yrs ago and it’s still perking along. They describe how to get the board out of the machine, not the easiest, but not super hard. Course, I’m the wife and hubby did the work. So that’s my story. For future, I would still get a front loader, but would definitely research which brand has best repair record. In years gone by, appliances lasted a good long time, but seems they are made to fail in short order nowadays.
Our refrigerator just gave an error code and it is 2 weeks shy of warranty date. Repairman coming out on Monday and that call will be covered. It’s an LG bottom freezer. But you are only interested in washer at the moment. Couldn’t help but blurt out about the frig…..
Let us know what your decision is.
Pat says
Us old timers do not like the HE machines, front or top load. And I finally found a machine that is supposed to be like the older type machines. The Speed Queen washer for $895.
Joanne in Zone 6b says
I bought a Bosch front-loading set when I moved nine years ago, mostly because I wanted machines big enough to wash my down comforters and I didn’t want an agitator. The wash gets clean and dry; the cycles take longer than they did on the traditional Maytag set I left in my previous home.
With the Bosch, I had the mold smell problems many writers have described; I use the same approach as Mundi (#19 ) to combat this, and it is effective. All of this said, if I ever have to buy a new washer-dryer, I will look for a nice, big, no-agitator top loader.
susie says
No one has mentioned this about front loaders:
Be sure to check for any critters in it before loading your clothes. We nearly lost our little cat, Possum. Fortunately, I caught where she was before the final spin or she would have been dead.
She suffered blunt force trauma, hypothermia, near drowning…she’s not the cat she was before her ordeal, but she’s mostly OK.
It’s much easier to see inside a top loader.
Laura Munoz says
Wow..Not sure you need my comment, but here it is anyway.
I own a Speed Queen. They cost more, but are made in the U.S.A. and come with a three year warranty. My Speed Queen is a top loader, but Speed Queen makes front loaders too. Prior to buying this machine, I bought a cheaper machine at a big box store and returned it within 2 days. I absolutely hated it.
My Speed Queen model does not have any computer parts that break and from my understanding in regard to all appliances that have computer parts, machines with computer parts are prone to malfunction and can be very expensive to fix. I do think Speed Queen makes some of their models with computer parts, but I specifically didn’t want those models.
My Speed Queen does NOT have a button you must push to open the lid once the machine is agitating or spinning. My machine also has a steel tub, not a plastic one. While the washing machine industry touts that those buttons make machines safer to use, I was told by an appliance man that the real reason manufacturers installed the buttons (computer chip) is that it makes the machine cheaper to manufacture than one that has a mechanical brake to stop it from agitating/spinning when you open it. I will never buy a washer or refrigerator with computer parts. All of my friends have them, and they break constantly.
I didn’t buy an energy efficient machine because I sometimes reuse my wash water to water my ornamental plants in the summer.
Frani says
My friendly serviceman tells me that when I get a new washer get a top-loading machine and get the cheapest model that will do what I need it to do. Foreign machines were not recommended. My 20+ year-old machine looks like it might be close to the same one you have. My machine is starting to look worn, but still washes perfectly. After hearing about all the problems with new machines, I hope mine lasts another 20.
Good luck and keep us posted!
Virgie says
When I saw your plea… I thought, okay, I’ll just tell Kevin my feelings. But, as I read this list of comments you already have, I can see that you don’t need to hear the same things repeated over and over again. I will say this. Even though I do not have the odor as frequently mentioned because I leave the door open overnight after a day of washing, I do have a grunge that stays inside of the large rubber seal around the tub. This is unsightly and gives me one more “opportunity” to shine as a domestic goddess but that is not my main complaint about the front loader washer. My biggest issue is it does not really clean my clothes. This is evidenced by the whites. It simply will not get whites clean. To me, if my whites aren’t clean, then what is? What about the darks and colors? I’m a 60 year young mother of two, family of four, that has a few (thousand) loads to her credit. My next washer is coming in a few months. It will be a top loader with a dasher. Speed Queen… I’m coming for you!
If you do decide to go with sexy, and let’s be honest here… we all did. Make sure the don’t open back to back… that’s no fun.
Joanne says
Hi- Don’t know if anyone will read this– 184th comment. I moved to this house in Maine to find a stacked Maytag pair. I have no basement and it’s Maine so can’t wash clothes in the garage. The Pair was possibly 6 years old when I got here. It’s been 26 years. Two, possibly three minor repairs to the electronics and the spin belt. My repair guy tells me to keep fixing it as long as he can get parts. He can’t get parts for the newer ones—any brand. Same problem with new fridges. My washer is a top loader and the dryer a front loader. We are remodeling the bathroom and these two old timers are staying put.
We purchased a new French Door fridge from whirlpool and the service guy condemned it 14 months later. Could NOT be repaired. I am done with the NEW. I buy only what my service guy can repair and replace.
Elaine R says
Wow! What a lot of comments. I’m in fear of my old top loader dying. I haven’t heard much good about front loaders . My neighbours have a Miele pair and when something goes wrong( as it has a few times) it meant carting it down to the next town,70 miles away, for service and waiting a week or more for parts. The local repairmen won’t touch it.so buy the best locally available.
As for the bottom of top loaders hard to reach….I am 4’9″ and I keep long handled salad tongs near the washer…I can even pick up laundered coins with it.
On the same lines, I miss my old dishwasher which washed better and faster than the new one which might save water but must use more power reheating the water.
Diann MacRae says
I’ve always had a top loader and, believe me, it’s the only kind I’d have. If you ever have a back ache, be sure to stay with a top loader.
sassysmom says
We bought a new washer and dryer set about 3 years ago, and we couldn’t even find a front load machine. Truthfully, I didn’t think that they were still making front load machines anymore.
Lynne Lillie says
If you decide on a front loader, be prepared to bend over–in more ways than one. I was so excited to get my first front loader a few years back–a Frigidaire–and I HATE IT. Mold and mildew are the first problem–and the solution: just leave the door hanging open. What the heck–who wants a beautiful machine that the door has to be left hanging open in order to avoid mold and mildew, plus that solution doesn’t really work and you have to be wiping and scrubbing the ring with a bleach solution regularly, which still doesn’t solve the problem. Not to mention that there’s no way to soak clothing; the low water volume may be efficient, but I’ve never felt it does as good of a job of cleaning. Plus, if your space is tight, that open front door to put in and pull out clothes is a real pain. My friend got a really high end front loader just a couple of years ago. I asked her how she liked it–“Well, I really don’t,” she said, “but it looks good.” So if it’s looks you’re after, I guess you’ll like the front loader, providing you like the looks of a washer with the door hanging open.
Elaine says
I am so lucky. I have my mother’s top load Maytag. It’s over 40 years old. That’s right 40 years and it still works beautifully. Never had to call the Maytag repairman. They don’t make like that any more.
Loraine Pross says
I have had both. Guess you will have fun sifting the 2 camps of opinion!
FIRST – ELECTRICITY IS not cheap, so pick a gas washer if you can!
SECOND – inevitably, 10 minutes after ‘turn on’, I find an article I REALLY want washed – NOW! Top loaders are easy to open; front NOT so much.
THIRD – front loaders usually have a rubber ring around the opening. Time-to-time, a small article manages to find its way in the opening. When I get it out, it’s wet, soapy & slimy :(. I have to wash & wring the article in the sink before adding it to the other items in the dryer!
MY next washer will DEFINITELY be a top loader!
Dominique says
Well Kevin,I live in New Zealand so brands might be slighly different than in the States, but I have had a top loader (7 kg) with agitator, not the drum for many years. They are brilliant. I don’t like the front loaders as you have to fold yourself in 2 to get all your washing out. They have drums, not agitator and they are not as efficient ( in my mind ) as the top ones. I wash sheets,duvet covers, drapes etc.. nothing tangles in it and they come lovely and clean. I guess you have a hard choice to make now !! You were lucky to keep your old one for so long as now days if you can keep any electrical ( white wear) for longer than 10 years, you are doing very well ! Good luck with your shopping and happy laundry!
Pat Crouse says
Purchased front loader washer around 6 years ago. Yes, they use less water, clean the clothes, and don’t lose socks like the older top-loaders did. But, there’s always a little water left on the rubber gasket and below. They doors have to be left open afterwards or you get mildew, and they don’t wring out the clothes as well so the dryer time has increased by 5+ minutes.
Dona says
Just keep the door ajar between use. Smell will not be around then.
Doreen says
I have an LG Direct Drive front loader that I LOVE!!! It uses much less water and cleans fabulously!!! I can clean my king size comforters without an issue.
As comment #207, your head must be spinning as fast as my front loader is at this very minute! Good luck with whatever you purchase.
Pat says
I agree with most of the comments here. I absolutely have come to hate my front loader, grunge in the seal, slow drying, mine is a Frigidaire. They say they save water, but you have to do extra loads because of the low capacity. Never again. Next one will be a top loader.
Nora says
Ok…here’s my input- I have been married 43 years and have done laundry for 5 children and a messy husband then; and, currently do laundry for 15 grandchildren and an even messier husband now. The old top load Kenmore from 40 years ago was my favorite and lasted 20 years. When it died I got water saving top load washers to replace it and I have gone through 3 that I was not impressed with. Low water and new agitation technology is awful. When the last one died three months ago (due to pot metal deteriation) I took my appliance repairman’s recommendation to purchase a commercial Speed Queen. FANTASTIC! Uses much more water but does an oh so amazing job on anything I throw in it. You can’t go wrong!
Denise in Colorado says
I moved to Colorado with my 10 year old Maytag top loading washer and dryer and they were still working great 15 years later when I decided to get rid of them and get new Maytag machines. They were so bad! I gave up on them last February and got new top loading GE machines at Sears. I love them! My sis has front loading and they smell musty, you can’t open them to toss in something you forgot to add etc. just saying! Good luck with your choice!
Debbie Tengler says
After 212 comments, you certainly don’t need my input but I also had a front loader and hated it. Top loader for me. My regular appliance serviceman advised against a front loader also. My daughter has a top loader with no agitator and loves it. I bought an older refurbished top loader years ago and it’s going strong.
Toni says
Hi Kevin. I bought a front loader to replace a top loader in my previous home. I inherited a front loader at this present house. Yes, for all the reasons listed above, I prefer a top loader.
The front loader twists and mangles clothes. You have to shake out every piece of laundry when putting it into the dryer or it will dry twisted and wrinkled. You cannot open it to add that one sock that fell to the floor once you press on.
I leave the washing machine door open when not in use.
Matt Locke says
Definitely go with the front loader. I was amazed at how much cleaner everything was as well as the savings on my water bill. I have three adorable ragdolls but their fur is everywhere. The front loader does a great job removing it and I am sure the dryer helps too. Good luck Kevin.
Matt
Ann G. says
I had to buy new top load washer and dryer last year and I live with my daughter and 4 month old grandson. I got whirlpool on sale at lowes and love them. They are the new energy type and no issues. My daughter uses cloth diapers and the washer cleans everything really well. I don’t want to have to bend over to put clothes into a machine. So for us the top load is ideal. We can add clothes if needed and we also use powder Oxy clean which elements odors. It has enough settings for all our uses.
Michele says
I have an older, eight years, Maytag top loader without the old agitator but has two steel drums that are set at outward angles that meet at the bottom. The clothes are tangled like you wouldn’t believe but other than that cleans clothes well if proper laundry detergent amount and quality used. It does sense the load so it will use the amount of water needed to wash the load. It has cycles that you can set for normal, whites, bulky, colors, normal etc you just can’t set the water level. I am sad to hear from comment above that Whirlpool bought out Maytag because they also bought out Kitchen Aide, a once trusted quality brand that is now made cheaper if you read reviews for Kitchen Aide dishwashers. I own a Whirlpool refrigerator and within two years motor went out. It is a shame trusted brands have sold out and American brands buy and then cheapen the quality.
Onnalee says
Front loaders were a necessity for me only because of the space I am dealing with.
Growing up with top loads, there are times I wish I still had one. There are times I wish I could scald my whites and let them sit in bleach or vinegar or oxy clean, but that’s not possible with a front loader.
Many have commented on the mold or mildew. Yes that happens if you close the door when you’re done. Also the tangling of clothes, yes I’ve pulled out Cami’s with ripped straps, and dress pants so wound tight I wonder if they are ever going to straighten out.
I will probably go back to a top loader when I purchase my next home.
Lynn says
I have a Miele front loader and love it. It’s over 20 years old and is as efficient as the day I bought it. No smells, no mould, no problems. It uses little water, doesn’t tangle the clothes and they come out so clean I’ve never needed to pre-soak anything, although it does have a pre-wash function.
I also have a Miele dryer, that sits on top of the washer. That’s brilliant too. It is so gentle on the clothes and I barely have to iron anything.
Go for the best – it’s worth it in the long run.
Linda says
I like my top loader better. I’ve had both and I like to peek inside during the cycle once in a while and make sure everything’s behaving. I can also add an article of clothing if I forgot. But, whichever you choose, get the extended warranty, because they just don’t make any of them to last. 🙂
Edna V says
Kevin, You have a lot of good comments from your readers. I have used top loaders for 50 years and love them. I don’t want to own a front loader after reading the comments.
My dad had a small front loader dryer and it took forever to dry one towel!
Not energy efficient at all. I still hang things in my basement to dry and then fluff them the next day in the dryer for 10 minutes.
Thanks for your amazing and candid thoughts in your newsletter.
mary forte says
Hi Kevin, I bought the extra large capacity Samsung front loader. It’s terrific. You can get so much more in it and it cleans super-great. I use Unicorn Fiber Wash & Rinse. Totally better than the normal Tide. http://www.unicornclean.com
Shelli DuBoff says
When I needed a new washer I spoke to our local appliance dealer about which one she would recommend. I was taken in by all the bells and whistles that come with some of the new pricey washers. Her recommendation was a Speed Queen. It’s a commercial heavy duty machine. Top loading completely made in the USA. Basic functions with no fancy parts that can break. Her selling point was that all the local farmers were getting them. And best of all it was less money than the other brands she had. I have not regretted it one bit. This washing machine holds a lot and it washes really well. I have recommended it to our vet who has loads of towels to do every day and all my horse friends who have heavy blankets to wash. For ordinary people with ordinary wash loads it’s the best!
David Henington says
I miss my top loader. We have a front loader. It no longer dispenses detergent or softener. It also doesn’t hold as much and gets out of whack easily and often. :(. I do like that they units can be stacked. When it dies I will look at a top load again. If you have the space I would recommend a toploader.
Georgeann Brown says
Please post your unscientific results and what you decided on to purchase.
Judy says
I recommend you find a machine as close to what you have as possible. It cleans faster and more efficiently than the new fangled models. I have a 2 year old top loader without an agitator and I dislike it intensely.
CONS
DOES NOT CLEAN AS WELL: Without an agitator there is no friction to clean the clothes, also less water means less cleaning ability. I have had loads that were still dry on top at the end of the cycle due to less water.
MORE EXPENSIVE: The soap is more expensive and the loads take twice as long to run through the cycles. You use more electricity for each load.
LOADS TAKE LONGER TIME: A normal load takes 57 mins not counting the 10 min to self balance the load. The quick clean takes 32 min with 10 min to self balance the load. Whites take 110 min etc.
MORE WORK: What I really hate is the bottom panel twists your clothes into knots and makes the load a tangled mess. Since they are spun dry like that, you get major wrinkles. You have to untangle all the clothes before you put them in the dryer
WON’T LAST AS LONG: Recalled within first year, repairman said they last about 8-9 years on average. My old one lasted 22 years and cost less than half the price.
PROS: Clothes come out dryer (albeit wrinkled) due to good spin speed. Many different setting options. Can add clothes after the cycle starts but you have to wait for the lid to unlock.
~~
All in all I regret buying this washer. Sorry for the dissertation, but I feel they took a good machine gave it more bells and whistles and made it worse.
Diane says
I’ve had a Frigidaire Gallery front loader washer and dryer for 15 years now and have had no problems and do love them! They’re also energy star so very efficient. One tip for front loaders I would pass on is keep the washer door open after you remove the clothes. It could be why people have problems with the front loader washer smelling. That doesn’t happen when you let it dry out! Also, cleaning the rubber and door occasionally is also a good idea. Just a little vinegar and warm water will keep it fresh! I’ve never had bad smells in mine. I highly recommend front loaders!
anne bretland says
HATE hate hate my front loader machine. Smells and you have to run it with a clean cycle – also not large enough. Have a LG HUGE top loader and I love it. Hhigh efficiency and senses the size of your load, big or small.
Jinx says
I’ve used both types and I HATE THE FRONT LOADER! 1) I want my clothes clean and not smellie when I take them out. I don’t find that in the front loader; nothing is ever moved around, with the front loader the water flattens the clothes and no agitation at all, just round and round you go. wen yu take them out they are almost in the same position as when you put the clothes in. 2) I want to be able to add water if needed or be able to move a blanket around or if I have delicate things, I want to be able to see what is happening to them while they wash. Lots of times, I find that they have washed enough, even on delicate cycle and I can stop the dam thing, you can’t on the front loader, you are stuck until you either pull the plug (and would the water drain out?) or get things damaged. Actually, how much water do you save with a front loader, my bills were almost the same. What you do is pay more for a front loader, same water bill, unclean clothes that smells, no control so who’s the winner? the manufacturer of the idiots, the money goes to them and your pocket is drained for a scam!!!! GIVE ME A TOP LOADER ANY TIME!!!
Alice H says
Bottom line – On the low end ($), Kenmore top loader is the best, on the high end ($) Speed Queen top loader is the best (ever!)
Washing machines are like magic – what goes in dirty, comes out clean.
Ellen says
WOW! you received a ton of great ideas. And this is nice because when we are all ready to purchase a new appliance, we can just check back on your email !!
Regarding a new washer, I have only had a top loading type. But I recently bought one from the neighbor. She just purchased the home and brought her own from her previous home.
Well this washer is terrible, now that I have experienced the new energy water save type, I know I will have to do my research from now on.
This washer is fine for washing but…..when it comes to the rinse cycle, there is only a few inches of water. In my book, my clothes are not being rinsed. I can see the soap buildup and dullness appearing before my eyes. My opinion, don’t get that rinse water saver 🙁
pat d says
Dont buy anything Samsung….. I’ve had more trouble with their products from tv’s to microwaves. I love my front loader washing machine from LG. If you clean the seal regularly (just wipe it dry when you are done and I leave the door open at night when I wash that day to air it out) I never have any trouble with it. I also use a vinegar rinse ( fill fabric softener tray wirh vinegar instead of softener) and have no smell in the clothes when they come out, my mother always did this and i think it helps get the soap out of your clothes. I also use the dryer ball (3) and I love them too. (tangled clothes should be shaken loose before putting in the dryer). Good luck with your choosing……
Elizabeth Wiggins says
My daughter HAD a front loader washer and dryer, she loved it for a while, but that while didn’t last very long. She got rid of both of them and got her and old timey top loader washer and front loader dryer. She has not had any more problems.
elda gray says
TOP LOAD- and only TOP LOAD…. We also bought a SPEED QUEEN. The are known for their commercial use in laundry mats. Large capacity and cleans your clothes. Reasonably priced.
Never considered a front load bec of all the complaints I heard from friends and neighbors who owned them.
Marsha Lockhart says
I believe the large efficiency front loaders are best for large families, as it washes and dries an enormous load of clothes. You must leave the door open when finished washing, so mold won’t form (need room to do that). A top loader is great for two or three people, but with most of the new models, you can’t open the washer door once the electronic controls are set and started (ex. add another towel). Sad to say, all new technology does not automatically mean convenience or time and money saved.
helen says
I like a top loader for several reasons. Had a front loader that leaked and flooded the laundry room. I was glad to get rid of it and got a top loader
. Another reason is that I can always open the lid on my top loader while it is filling up to add more dirty clothes (I am a forgetful old lady). Try doing that when a front loader is filling up with water … lol.
Connie Cozzini says
One more opinion… Front load Whirlpool set purchased 10 years ago. Top of the line. Never a single service call on either unit. One Must gently wad sheets and large bulky items. I’ve kept the door open on the washer after hearing others had problems. I’ve only cleaned it once in 10 years. No odor problems. Washer holds a lot of items, much more than any top loader I have ever owned. I do miss being able to soak things, but it has a pre-wash cycle I have used for this. My clothes are always clean and smell well. Anxious to hear your decision.
Michelle says
Hey Kevin,
I still have the top load Whirlpool that come with my house from 20 years ago. We just got our 3rd dryer and I dread the day when old faithful Whirlpool no longer works.
That said, I say find a top load machine. IF you can still find one with an agitator, please stay old school. My friends had their no agitator, we can sense your load for you washers. I mean really hate them. Good luck!
JoAnn Stiever says
TOP LOAD, by all means! With 5 options of water-level filling on my high-capacity washer, I control just how much water I WANT to use. Once a wash cycle has started, I still can add an item I may have forgotten. I also learned that I get the cleanest wash by USING LESS SOAP AND MORE WATER! Good luck with your search.
Patricia Bell says
Hi Kevin,
Boy have you received a load of answers! I had a Kenmore front loader for about 14 years. Never had a single problem with it and no mold or smell ever. One morning it simply quit with no warning. The control panel had died and it would have cost as much as a new washer to replace it. Needless to say I bought a new washer. Front loader and it is a Whirlpool with a direct drive motor. It washes just fine and holds a large amount of wash. My Kenmore would hold 18 bath towels and that’s a lot.
I am pleased with the Whirlpool, clothes are clean and not all bunched together when finished washing. I keep it clean and wipe out after each wash so there won’t ever be a smell.
I honestly think you should buy the one that suits your fancy. Besides they are all pretty much alike. And the Whirlpool had excellent ratings and was on sale! Good luck!
Kate says
My advice is to get a Speed Queen top loader with no electronics, just the old fashion dials, which is what my appliance repairman recommended to me. I have had top and front loaders from so many brands, mid-range to high end, and I am tired of replacing motherboards, etc from the electronics going haywire. A Bosch front loader I had didn’t mildew like the Whirlpool I have now, but electronically it was a pain. I bought a Speed Queen for a rental unit, to replace the Bosch, and the tenants are so happy with it, and I haven’t had any more expensive repair calls.
Good luck!
Scott T. says
Kevin…
My old reliable washer died a couple years ago. Would have cost more to fix it than to buy a new one. When I went out shopping I was shocked at how much washer technology had changed!! I find it difficult to change with the times… I still don’t even own a cell phone. An iPad is about my extent of modernity. LOL. So I really wanted a top loader. I eventually ended up deciding on an LG high efficiency top loading washer. My washer/dryer are down in my basement so anything too sleek and sexy would just have been a waste of money since no one but me ever sees them. I was initially amazed at how little water these new machines use… and a bit skeptical they would really clean my clothes. I work at a greenhouse so there are days my clothes are rather gritty and grimey. I was delighted to see just how well they really do clean clothes. I would never get a front loader. Everyone I know who has one has had some sort of catastrophe with it. Either the seals develop mold and mildew or, like my brother, they leak all over… flooding the house and causing thousands of dollars of damage to hardwood floors.
Faye says
Top loader for sure! Ditto to all the negative comments above regarding front loaders. Good luck on your quest.
Mary says
Kevin, I would ignore the advice from people who have had their washers for 9 years or more, as the washers are no longer made like those. I would find a brand that is not high energy and that allows you to make the decisions regarding spin speed and water level. In keeping with that advice I would avoid all Kenmore and Whirlpool products.
Lgb says
Trust me please. Keep what you have! I had heard not to dare buy a front loader – various reasons like it’s doesn’t clean clothes!!! So I bought as close as I could to the old fashioned top loader- they don’t come w agitators anymore. It just fills with water maybe spins a little (not much cause we are saving energy here – –and just a little water cause we are saving resources) you are getting my drift here I hope. My clothes come out just as dirty as when I put them in. I’m barely exadurating though I am. Point is -BUY A TOP LOADING Old fashioned machine WITH AN AGITATOR!!! If you can find one.
Janice says
I had a broken knob on a washing machine and ordered the part online and no problem! Works like a dream.
Frieda Hickman says
We were talked into a top loader and they have been great. It uses less soap and water as mentioned. But more important it saves my back as I don’t have to bend over to get clothes out of the dryer. The brand we have now is Fisher&Paykel. Previously I had husband build a wooden box about 9inches tall to sit dryer on so I did not have to bend down so low. I’m taller than average height for women.
Ron Falcone says
We just went through this.
Luckily (?) whatever you pick, you probably won’t have to live with the mistake very long. Appliances aren’t made to last very long. Our first washer & dryer lasted us 30 years. In the last 15 years we’ve gone through 3 sets.
This time around we did our research and found that the high efficiency models have problems getting cloths clean. The ratings weren’t encouraging. The front loaders also can have problems with mold growing around the drum.
We wanted a washer that didn’t have electronics as that’s just something else to go wrong and is expensuve to replace.
We found what we think is the perfect washer for us. Top loading, no electronics, stainless tub, an agitator, good at cleaning the cloths, a good warrantee. Take a look at Speed-Queen.
emmer says
who knew there was so much passion over washing machines???
I have a 4 year old maytag he front loader. it did develop that funny smell and I eventually read about what to do. water apparently can pool on various whatsits in the machine’s innards, and thereby allow mold to grow. there is a commercial product, afresh, that is supposed to be used once a month to prevent/cure the problem. it mostly works. the product is mostly washing soda, so I use that instead, mostly. the rubber gasket does want to hold water. you must be vigilant in drying it out after you last load of the day. don’t jam it tightly full and it won’t make a tangle-y mess. I love the 1200rpm spin. I love how little dryer fluff I have in the dryer filter, assuming that is because the washer abrades the clothing less. this machine can do a load decently on 11 gallons. my old top loader used 40 gallons. with the much smaller amount of water used, I don’t feel extravagant doing a load in hot water (which reduces the chances of that musty smell all by itself (maybe hot water evaps off those innards better than cold?).
Jane Wilder-O'Connor says
Whatever you choose, my suggestion is to never use fabric softener or bleach. Add 1/4-1/2 cup white distilled vinegar in place of liquid bleach or fabric softener. Add a few drops of lavender or lemon EO if you need the aroma. Toss two wool dryer balls in the dryer to hasten the drying process and reduce static electricity, once again a few drops of essential oil on the wool dryer balls provide a delicate freshness.
Sheri Rice says
Oh good heavens are you sorry you asked. Opinions are clearly quite varied!
I’m speaking as someone obsessed with laundry. I do a load every day, although I hate folding. My husband and I have a teensy laundry room off the kitchen and I would note your space when considering the format you buy. The front loaders obviously need more space to open the door to load, and I find them harder to load just because it’s awkward. Some people put them up on a stand so they are easier to access.
I used to own (inherited in my first house) a fabulous old Maytag top loader but it probably used too much water…..but I loved it.Never had issues, worked like a charm. It was metal (new ones are plastic) and I never had a problem in 10 years with it. The brand we have now is Frigidaire, they are metal, and both washer & dryer seem to work well, and I have not had the “moldy” smell (but we do leave the washer door open and I use chlorine bleach ONLY on my 100% cotton white towels once/month). I don’t seem to have an odor issue. I have to also say Persil has been great as a detergent. I use the pods and I’ve heard you’ll save money by using less detergent if you use pods, most of us over-measure in the cups.
PS if you really want to save energy, hang a clothesline in your basement. And/or wash your clothes on cold/warm vs. piping hot water. And/or divert the brown water and save it to water your garden (my mom does this with no ill effects to her plants). It’s better for your clothes anyway to wash in cooler temps. The water savings is a nice thing but if you have to wash your clothes twice to get them clean, are you really coming out ahead?
Margo says
Kevin-I owned a laundromat with top loaders and front loaders. Yes, the wash is longer than with a top loader but the drying takes minutes less b/c of the max extract.
I put my maytag frontloader on a pallet (cheap!), unscrewed the door light, and leave the door open a few inches when not in use. Have had 13 yrs with no issues. At cycle end the tub reverses to fluff the wet clothes. HE soap is critical less you want to replace expensive gaskets. You use less water, soap, and electricity. Have had no issues with clothes cleanliness. Tough clothes put on the pre-wash cycle. It washes longer and the clothes soak in the machine. Any smell issues are likely due to the local water the users have. Would never go back to a top loader ! Let us know which you choose please!
Robin says
I DO NOT recommend the LG top loader. Although I would still stick with a top loader. In the last 18 months, we’ve had 7 service calls and my machine is still not running right. I’ve been without a washer for the last 3 weeks because I’m waiting for the warranty company to get a replacement mother board. When this part comes in, I believe the warranty company has replaced every possible part they can. This has been the biggest lemon of a machine I have ever owned. I want to go back to a basic washing machine without all the bells & whistles! My recommendation is that you keep it as simple as possible! Good luck 🙂
Ardelle says
Ohhhh, I am feeling very, very fortunate these days. My washer and dryer date from 1990 – Maytag, top of the line at the time – extra large capacity. I have it serviced every few years – 3-5 by the best appliance repair man in the world. He keeps encouraging me to treat it well because the new ones last 2-3 years at best. Plastic parts, technology that fails, poor finish –
I dread thinking that eventually it may bite the dust and/or my much loved repair person retire or moves. I always leave it open after use and it drys out I clean or replace the exhaust venting, vacuum in every area that I can get to. Yes, I feel very fortunate – it works perfectly. Seen lots of teenager jeans, glitzy clothing, now grandchildren’s clothing, blankets, sandy beach stuff.
Good luck Kevin I can understand your trepidation – friends of mine rant and rail about the utter failure of the washers and driers now on the market.
Sylvie from Montréal says
We’ve had our LG front load washer for 4 years now and we love it. We can wash very large loads. The features I especially like are the handwash/wool cycle, the allergiene cycle and the timer. I can wash very delicate items and they will keep their shape. The allergiene cycle is great for removing the stinky smell off towels. We’ve never had problems with molds or a smelly tub. There is a system that allows you to leave the door slightly ajar and that is enough to keep the tub fresh between loads. In short, we consider we made a good buy and so is the dryer that comes with it.
Heike Woolard says
Dear people that have a front loader and complain about the smell. Please, I beg you be sensible, take a towel and dry the rubber seal and for goodness sake, leave the door open. I do NOT understand, why this is so hard to comprehend.
I grew up with a front loading washing machine and we ALWAYS did this. It is in the instruction booklet. Does not anyone read this???
I have a 2008 Samsung washer. It is big. Takes King size comforters, King sizes Duvet, fitted sheet, 4 pillow cases and a blanket. 10 big fluffy towels. A weeks worth of my husbands nasty laundry, either from Truck driving or Commercial fishing, whatever he is doing at the moment. I also do small loads. All the clothes always come clean and boy’o I do NOT use a lot of soap either.
My Grandma came over here to the US in 1991, when my daughter was born, she saw the stove (the one with the coils) and gave me this look… then she saw the washer. She said, oh yeah, I had one of those before the war… WWII she meant. Then she proceeded to tell me if we had traveled back in time. I’m just going to leave this with you.
Buy a front loader, if you can leave the door open and dry the rubber seal. If that’s too much, go with a top loading machine.
PS: My two girls, Maggie and Sugar, asked me to give a shout out to Ms. Lily.
Jan Penny says
Hi Kevin! Thank you for your interesting articles and delicious recipes. Regarding a top loading washing machine as opposed to a front loading machine, I do have an opinion. I always had a top loading machine until 7 or 8 years ago. One thing I liked about a top loading washer is that I could control how much water I put in it. That way I could soak an item that had a stain on it. You can’t do that with a front loading machine. My Whirlpool Duet does a very good job of getting my clothes clean, but there’s not a soaking option. It’s true that to avoid black mold from building up at the bottom of the rubber seal where some water collects after each load. It is necessary to wipe the water out of the seal. My machine has a cleaning mode on it and bleach is added and it is to get rid of the mold. I do this about once a month. My machine never smells bad because I follow those instructions. I want to get a top loader next time for the above reasons. Thank you.
Sue says
I will never go back to a top loading machine-
my clothes come out much cleaner using the front load
Peggy says
I did the same thing last year when the ancient washer which came with our home went kaput – went online and asked friends for a recommendation! Everyone who responded recommended the LG WT1701C High Efficiency. We got it and have had no problems and are very pleased with it.
One drawback if you are vertically challenged, is you may need a one-step stepstool to get all the laundry out as the drum is deep. My cousin has the same brand/model as I, but had hers special ordered with a shorter drum so she can reach the drum bottom.
Ours does all sizes of loads and has many special functions which are easy to use.
Louise says
I have a Frigidaire washer – front loading bought because it rarely needs repair. My house is 40 miles to any big city so repairs would be expensive. The installer recommended we unplug it between uses. Several machines in an area break because of a message sent to the machine. If it’s unplugged, it can’t be sent.
Anne says
Well, I’m really late to the parade(!), but thought I’d add in one comment that I haven’t seen posted yet (although the point has been inferred). A co-worker of mine had an older machine (inherited with her house), and needed to do a minor repair. She really wanted to replace the washer/dryer with newer sexy versions (against her mother’s advice)- and asked the repairman for his advice. She was most interested in environmentally friendly features. His answer (which I’ve since seen repeated many times over, and which her mother had already told her): the old machines were built to last, and to be repaired and keep going. They may use more water, but they work better. Environmentally, even with the most high end features on a new machine it will be difficult or impossible to repair, will have a much shorter lifespan, will probably require disposal in a landfill at it’s end of life, etc… It’s much more environmentally friendly to repair and keep the old one. Also, or so I’ve been told, you could never save enough water/power etc… over its lifetime to replace the cost of scrapping a machine that could still have been useful for many more years – either financially or environmentally.
Replacing less-energy efficient but still usable and fixable appliances with sexy high-efficiency new ones that aren’t as robust is a great example of green-washing. You’d be better off to stay with the old machine, but switch to environmentally friendly cleaning products (like washing soda, borax, baking soda, and vinegar).
Bonnie says
Top Loader if you like the smell and feel of clean clothes. Get the fancy dryer. It is wonderful. The sensors work and save you money.
Anne says
Oh, I should add: that last comment – at least as told by the repairman – applies to the washing machine. There may be more of an argument for replacing the dryer with a higher-efficiency one. But his argument there was that if you’re looking to help the environment nothing beats a clothesline for energy efficiency, environmental good stewardship, and getting your clothes clean.
Jane says
To Anne’s point….I had the top loader for I do not know how many years…..it was that old. It died and so I replaced it with the front loader because it was supposed to be efficient, new and whatever else. I do not notice mildew issue, but here’s what I do not like about a front loader:
1) You cannot soak clothes like you can with a top loader
2) It shakes a lot and is loud
3) It does nothing better of worse in terms of cleaning clothes
4) It may use less water (so they say), but I find it takes 1/2 the amount of clothing of a front loader so I do not think it is efficient to run twice as many loads.
5) It take s long time to do a load and you cannot really adjust it to have short cycle like you can with a top loader.
Here’s what I like about the front loader:
It probably won’t last and I can go back to a top loader.
Michelle says
SPEED QUEEN for the win! Our previous washer was a GE top load. It died a few months after the warranty ran out. Didn’t like it much anyway. Clothes never smelled clean and it took forever to run a load of wash. I read reviews and more reviews. Then came across all the great reviews for Speed Queen. We went to take a look and made the purchase that day. It is a heavy duty, top load washer without frills. And, it actually uses a sufficient amount of water to clean clothes. Even though we live in California, I want water in my washing machine! It does have a low water cycle, should you want to use it. I have not tried it. They say they are built to last 25 years and they have a great warranty. Clothes now smell clean and wash quickly and quietly. We are very happy with our purchase. Price was around $900. incl tax.
Michelle says
Oh! And with Speed Queen, you can open the washing machine lid! The machine just stops instantly, no screeching halt. So many machine won’t allow this now. I heard that this may chance in the future but I can not confirm this. Good luck in your search!
Richard says
I’ve always had TOP loaders and have done well with them.
One problem I’ve had in the past a few times, yrs ago, was when a Front
door machine stops working for whatever reason it is usually full of water and one can’t usually get the door open w/o getting the Water ALL
over the Place. O/C if that’s in the laundromat, I wouldn’t have to clean
it up…. Just sayin’ !
Jeff says
Was gonna say I’ve never owned a front-loader but from what I’ve read and heard, I wouldn’t take a chance on one either. Most top-loaders are so much more efficient now-a-days anyway, and it looks like I’m with the majority here. Good luck whichever way you go!
Mary says
I’ve had top loaders and now have front loaders and have not seen any difference in cleaning. I read some but not all of the comments. I did not see this advice in the comments I read – only use powder detergent in a front loader. Apparently, liquid detergent has something (oil-?) in it that can contribute to the musty/mold problem. I’ve had no issue with this, but I leave the door ajar and use powder detergent.
I miss my top loader for several reasons – the spin only option, the extra large capacity, the ability to add items and change the amount of water mid cycle, the ability to easily pre-soak/bleach, the ability to dye items.
While I agree with conserving overall and my front loaders are HE, water is not in short supply in my area and I would prefer to have my old top loader back.
Good luck!
Beverly says
I have chemical sensitivities and cannot use scented detergents. HE washing machines are designed for city use where you pay for water usage, so, they are “efficient” in that they don’t use much water. Problem is they also don’t clean your clothes. I use unscented detergents and find I must wash each load twice to remove odors. Kind of undoes the whole “efficiency” of the machine. This is why laundry detergents are soooooo scented. It is to mask the fact that the clothes are not really clean. I have never used a front load machine, so, I don’t know anything about them. It is very hard now to find a large capacity washing machine that is not HE. I would rather wash clothes in a wash tub and use a wringer than have an HE washer.
Tauni says
I have used a front-loader for 40+ years and wouldn’t have any other kind. Now that said, my washer is in the basement and I leave the door open but I would think any washer left closed would get funky smells 🙂
Much gentler on your clothes, I can wash hand-wash only items in it with no problems.
Karen Aamodt says
Front loader all the way! Why: you can pretend you’re Lucy while you sit next to the machine and watch the clothes go round and round. Plus side: NO agitator to irritate your clothes!
Laura says
Not sure that you will get to my comments, but in case you do, here goes. I had a Maytag Top-loader for years that I loved. When it died, I did a lot of research and settled on the LG front loader. (I purchased the pedestals for both the washing machine and dryer, and it makes all the difference — I learned that the hard way after buying a front loader Whirlpool model for our cottage. It is such a pain having to practically crawl in to get the clothes out!) I have come to LOVE the front loaders. Even though I had the largest capacity Maytag available for the home market, I was only able to fit one set of sheets and two bath towels in at a time. These new machines are HUGE! I have four kids, and now have to run loads half as often as I used to, because I can put so much more in each load. It has totally changed how I do laundry! And, I have never had mold issues with either of them, even though the cottage one sits idle for months at a time. I’ve had that one for nine years, and the LG for four. I like the LG a little bit better, as it has more options and is faster. The quick setting is only 30 minutes, and is great for sheets and towels. Front loaders also spin the clothes much more, cutting way down on dry time. Win-win for me. Btw, my LG does have a soak and rinse setting, and a spin setting, so sometimes, if I have a particularly filthy item, I will soak it in a pail overnight, then dump the whole mess in and spin and rinse it before washing.
Julie R says
We had the same top loading washer for 28 years. It finally died a few months ago, and I replaced it with another top loading washer, of the same brand as the one that died. It was a Kenmore. The salesman at the store, tried to talk me into getting a much fancier kind of washer that was much more expensive, but I had already done my research on line before heading to the store and knew what I wanted. I am very happy with the new washer. It doesn’t have all the bells and whistles that many of the newer washers have, but I knew what features that I wanted it to have for our needs. The simple top loading washer would do the trick for my family. Our new washer does use much less water, than it’s older ancestor, which is good. There is a reason why I wanted to stay with a top loading washer. I have troubles with my back and it is easier on my back to load the washer from the top, rather than having to bend down to load it and and unload it. Good luck in your washer search, Kevin.
Barb Gilligan says
Can’t go wrong with a ‘Speed Queen’ They are well built….perhaps top of the line in washers & dryers, they are commercial grade made for home use. No cheapness in their parts, old fashioned quality, runs quiet too, no smells from the rubber gasket. I have the front loader, but you can get the top loader if you prefer. No gimmicks just sound quality, they have the best warranty out there. Speed Queen only make washers & dryers, they have for many years. They used to only make commercial ones, but now make commercial grade ones for home use. They are a bit pricey but well worth it. Be sure you order them with the doors on the correct side, so they open the way you want them to.
Cathy McBride says
Your comment and review is my favorite!!
Sherry Pace says
Top loader! We did a lot of research a couple years ago when we needed a new washer/dryer. For all the reasons everyone mentioned above – ease of loading (not having to purchase expensiv pedestals) and not having to bend over to load , avoiding funky smells, larger capacity, spin option, ability to pre-soak, different load sizes, no flood if it stops in the middle of the cycle and you have to open the door, and lastly price. We would gladly pay a little more for a better product, but won’t pay just to have the latest, greatest, keep up with the neighbors…We ended up purchasing the LG brand with no agitator. We went to a big box store in January and purchased on sale, with free delivery and take away of our old washer. There were mainly two negative comments posted by other purchasers – it was deep and hard to reach the bottom, and it didn’t always work well with small loads – having difficulty balancing the load. It is deep! However, at 5’1′ all washers are too deep for me. Step stool by the washer – problem solved. I frequently wash small loads of delicates and have never had a problem. I do sometimes have to reach in and re-distribute when doing a heavy load like a comforter. The other benefit of the LG is that the front of the lid is hinged. It can be locked in place to form a solid lid, or unlocked and folded back to air the washer out without leaving the lid open (something I was nervous about with the kitty). Hope this helps, good luck with your purchase.
Ed Morrow says
If you want a stackable washer/dryer (it is a big space saver) a front loader is the only way to go. We’ve had one for almost 10 years with no problems and it does an okay job. Good luck with whatever you choose and keep us posted on what you decide.
Edie says
Hi Kevin! Wow, so many comments! I would look at Consumer Reports and online reviews of a particular model you think has merit. I have stacked LG front loaders. Sometimes “new idea” means new work methods. Mine has been all around great for 4 years. Small and large loads accepted, pre-treat function, rinse and spin for hand washables as well as a “handwash” cycle. Love the steam cycle and thanks to another reader I am trying the “Allergiene”cycle right now. Oh and bending over and reaching up is bonus exercise for me, yay!
L.K.D. says
I JUST had to have a front load washer. Water left rust stains around the door . You could not
keep the door closed after washing, because the smell would be horrible and so you had to leave the door open all the time. We finally got a heavy duty top loader and it is so much better. I love my top loader.
Ana says
Good Luck
FYI : Our front loader door burst open during the cycle and forcefully flooded our house.
They do get stinky
They are efficient
They look pretty cool
Someone in a magazine said they clean clothes better
They wrinkle clothes better
Most of the water is removed from your clothes
I am pretty sure most of them are possessed
Sue says
Hi Kevin,
I bought the Samsung front loaders about 10 years ago and have hated them since day one. Previously I had whirlpool too loader and loved it cause could presoak my clothes. Great when u have very stained kids clothes. Anyhow the front loader I thought would be like one we had in europe that cleaned great. Turns out here in North America the drum doesn’t fill with water like they do in Europe. The drum only fills slightly with water. I feel like the clothing barely gets wet. The machine runs forever while my old one did a load in 20 minutes. In my mind what’s the point of saving energy if you are barely even wetting the clothing. Wouldn’t want another set even if they gave them to me. Now I have heard that the Miele front loaders are very good from an appliance store owner friend of mine. I will definitely research before buying again and I know too loaders are making a huge comeback but they are also now high efficient and don’t use as much water so wonder if the best thing would be to try and buy an old school one which will actually do what they are meant to do – wash! Good luck and thanks for all your enjoyable posts!
Cat says
Several years ago I decided to upgrade our washer & drier. They still worked, but I wanted to upgrade to something efficient and with as much capacity as I could get. I wanted them large enough to accommodate my oversized comforters, since the dry cleaning bill on those hurt my feelings. That and I hate paying other people to do things I can do myself. I purchased the Whirlpool cabrio, high efficiency combo. We use half of the detergent and fabric softener that we used to and they really cut down on loads. I chose a top loading washer and a front loading drier. The washer has settings for heavy duty or bulky items (gotta love that), delicates or just a quick wash for those new items. I can’t wear new clothes without washing them first. I love, love, love my drier. It handles delicate to heavy duty loads, but I like that it has a quick refresh and a touch up option. Saves me time from ironing. The other nice option is the wrinkle shield. Since our laundry is in the basement, I often forget about it. The wrinkle shield keeps things fluffed until I get back down to retrieve them. Fewer loads, less detergents & energy used and they do a wonderful job cleaning. If they last as long as my old ones did, they’ll be the last set I have to buy, so worth every penny. Hope that helps and I love your site!
debra says
Fisher Paykel. Best. Washer. Ever.
https://www.fisherpaykel.com/us/laundry/washing-machines/washing-machine/washsmart-22lb-steel-lid.WA3927G1.html
shirley welch says
Purchase a basic top loader, they have been around for years and are proven. Front loaders cost more, need more repairs which are more expensive and don’t usually last as long. A nice plain work horse of a top loader is the only way to go. Good luck on your purchase !
Sharon says
I have always had a top load washer. After listening to friends who bought front loaders I would never own one. They break down, have mold & tangle problems.
sandy says
Speed Queen! Highly recommended by the appliance repair person in my location. No complicated parts to replace. Old fashioned quality that lasts.
Julia L Owings says
Okay…been there , done that and back again LOL
I had front loader, if the door seal goes out it’s expensive to replace. If you forget something you can not add it in. For that fact alone I would do a top loader…until I am in a wheelchair and have to have a front loader.
Another note is if they are HE the electric bill will be higher as they take LONGER to wash. Don’t go by wash cycles, because some don’t include the time of rinse and spin in those times…lived and learned.
If you have power surges in your area, get a power strip especially if you have all computer in the washer.
All said and done, what did I chose…a WRINGER WASHER…yep sure did.Got it at auction for $65 and it runs. Have had it for 4 yrs now and the only problem was a loose bolt that Hubby fixed.I could have fixed but he wanted to check to make sure all the bolts were tight.
Check reviews of what the buyers are saying not so much of what is listed as the top ten. We looked at 2 of the top ten this week and when I checked the consumer reviews I would have not been happy.
Shelley says
DO NOT BUY A FRONT LOAD WASHING MACHINE…ESPECIALLY A BOSCH!!!!! In reading the comments I was amazed at how many people hated their front load washing machines! Me too!!! My husband had to have a Bosch in Anthracite…because he loves Bosch tools and he felt the washer should be top of the line! Silly man. I so miss my old Maytag top load washer! I will never let my husband pick an appliance again (he also chose our new fridge, a Kenmore with a bottom drawer freezer…hate it…the bottom drawer is like a big, deep ice chest and I literally have to dig everything out from what seems like an endless pit and risk frostbite! Give me a side-by-side refrigerator any day! Back to the washer…I read in a comment that you have to buy high end, like Bosch, to avoid the mold and smell…NOT TRUE! My Bosch smelled so bad after awhile I called up the company to ask what the heck is going on! She told me I had to “wash my washer!” Never heard of such ridiculousness! She wanted me to buy a washer wash! Oh well, needless to say, I just dry my washer very well (including inside the rubber door seal…which is the main stinky culprit) after I am done using it for the day. Another negative for my Bosch washer is that IT DOES NOT CLEAN THE CLOTHES AND THEY COME OUT SMELLING HORRIBLE, SOMETIMES!!!! I HAVE TO WASH THEM TWICE!!! What a waste of time, electricity and water. But, that is the problem, they have made the new washers so water efficient they cannot wash the clothes properly. Anyway, sorry for rambling on about my Bosch…I just don’t want anyone to make the same mistake I did!
Kh says
Just have it fixed the new ones are very problematic. Front loaders suck.
Dee Dee from Washington State says
I have Kenmore Elite front loaders sitting up on pedestals and I love them! My husband and I got them as an engagement gift from his parents 8 years ago and we couldn’t be happier. The only problem we have ever had is if you do a big load of socks, some get stuck in the flange at the front of the washer. All you need to do is remove them and ‘drain and spin’ again and all is well. Good luck with your search and Happy Valentine’s Day to you and the Silver Fox!
Susan Romasco says
Top loader. By far the best choice. When placing the wet clothes into the front loading dryer, many of them just fall on the floor first.there is also no way to soak clothes or to open the machine if you’ve found a stray to throw in after the machine is running..
Diane Var says
Hi Kevin,
Wow, you got so many responses. Anyway, I have a front loader and love it. I’m on my second one now and am very happy with it. You may hear about those complaining that it smells, etc. I’ve never had that problem as I’ve always left the door open. The only draw back to this is if your washer is in a high traffic area, this may not work for you. Mine is in the basement. Good luck with your choice.
mags says
Dear Kevin, I’ve had a front loading washing machine for years and never had any problems with it (Whirlpool btw). I usually clean it out once a month with a tablet and never had odors and/or mildew! I LOVE it.
Your reader Julia stated that “if you forget something you cannot add it in”! Well I beg to differ on my front loader. You can stop the cycle and add extra clothes if you forget something. I guess it depends on the make/model. So make sure it has features you feel you need!
Happy Shopping!
ps Diane is right – always leave the door open to avoid smells and mildew!
brenda treants says
Front loader. Because it is better than top loader. Because.
brenda treants says
This thing asked for another answer. So here goes. Front loader is better than a top loader. Because I said so.
Jen says
According to the repairman, hang on to older large appliances (get them repaired)…as newer large appliances are made with parts which, when they break down, are often not serviceable or replaceable. (Planned obsolescence)
Constantine says
Sewer Systems
Hi Kevin,
One other thing to consider is the state of your sewer line. My husband and I discovered that our house, built in the early 50’s, has clay tile pipes to the city sewer line. We had a back up and the plumber that came to the rescue schooled me on the fact that when our house was built, toilets and washers were sending larger amounts of water through the lines, therefore moving waste out of the pipes. Since we remodeled with low water toilets, dishwasher, and clothes washer, low flow shower heads, the volume of water is too low to effectively move the waste out of the lines and therefore it builds and clogs. Something that we can expect to have happen again, and again.
So consider you sewer system when you decide on a washer – maybe that water inefficient low tech top loader will actually be the best choice for you pipes!
Good luck. Let us know what you decide.
Elaine Wilmes-Pandolfo says
Oh my…this was a controversial topic! We bought a front loading washing machine when moving into our new energy efficient home. It is a Kenmore (energy star rated). Sears is not a fav. of mine but they have awesome sales and we were equipping…..and building a new house. It is really efficient and accomadates large loads, or 20 minute mini loads for stuff that is not really dirty, just in need of refreshing. Re. complaints about odor, it is very easy to regularly wipe down the machine’s gaskets, and run a short cycle with vinegar added. I make my own detergent and use only cold water as the agitation is the main way clothes get cleaned.
Chrissie says
Kevin,
I’ve had both. I love my front loader the best. When after 17 years mine goes, I will purchase another front loader. In the meantime, I have been looking at them and talking with various people about brands. Sounds like LG front loaders for this years models are really good.
Beverly says
I commented once on your washing machine question. I am now reading many of the comments from other people and want to add one more comment. Many people are pointing out that you cannot add to the load once it has started in a front loader. In my experience, you can’t do that in a top load HE washer either. The lid locks. You have to hold the button in forever for it to unlock so you can open the lid. Then, it drains out all of the water (and detergent) and starts over. You could not pay me to have a HE washer.
Linda A says
I bought a Speed Queen top loader a year ago and love it. I bought the model for the year
prior rather than the latest model. And I bought it from a local appliance store that’s been in business forever in my town because I knew they’d be far easier to deal with than a big box store if there were any problems.
I didn’t want a machine that registers the load and adjusts the water level accordingly because if you open the lid and add an extra item, it starts the cycle all over again. And those water saver machines take forever to get through a single wash. (Who wants to take all day – or several days as may be the case with these slow machines – to do the wash?)
Also, I like to knit and then felt the item. To do so, I need a machine I can start and stop frequently.
The machine I had before this was a Sears Kenmore, which years ago was a decent machine but, no longer. The machine leaked after three months. The repair man said all the parts are imported and cheaply made. The upside is this keeps his job as a repair man secure. I had it repaired but I should have thrown it out. It worked a bit longer and then started leaking again.
Also, names like Maytag are not really the Maytag machines from the past. Many companies have merged. Believe Maytag is owned by Whirlpool. It’s a jungle out there – good luck!
Carolyn Yost says
I have a Bosch and like it, but next time I will buy a Miele because it has a longer warranted and I feel it will clean better.
PT says
Go with a top loader that uses a full tub of water. I like Speed Queen.
Anything that doesn’t use a full tub of water will do nothing but abrade the surface of the fabric so you will need to replace your items sooner. It seems foolish to me to swap some water charges for replacement wardrobe charges.
Whatever you do enjoy it… but don’t listen to the salespeople who are just out to sell the most expensive one possible!
Connie Chard says
Speed Queen top loader is THE BEST! We have had ours for about 8 years now..love it! Before we got this machine I actually contacted a washing machine service repair man who had been doing this for many many years. He suggested I go with the top loader because front loaders are nothing but trouble. Good luck Kevin!
Michelle says
Re: Speed Queen top loading washers
My local appliance store sales person said they are hands down the best. However, she did say that beginning around July (2017) or so, they will change their design (mandatory compliance with energy/water regulations) and that she was going to buy one before then (and she doesn’t even need a washing machine right now). Just a heads up for those who read this thread and are in the search mode.
Roberta Melsheimer says
I am using a front loader given to us by a friend. I had one before and it would get moldy around opening. The only way around that is to leave your door ajar after a wash. I will sometimes use a Young Living Thieves cleaning spray and squirt the inside to kill anything that thinks it might want to invade the washer. I also use a pretty clean detergent, with baking soda and white cider vinegar in the softner holder. I dont use fabric softner but I do use wool dryer balls which help dry the clothes quicker. I got a little carried away….. I have had both types of washer machines and I would opt for the top loader as I dont want to take any chances of having any kind of mold in my washer or on my clothes. I never could get rid of the mold in my washer. But if you do opt for the front loader… keep the washer door ajar after the wash so the tub can dry out!! Good Luck!
Pat says
Ironically, not long after this my hated, frontload Frigidaire stopped draining. It was a choice between purchasing a 1-year $299.99 service contract to see if it could be repaired, but at nearly 10 years old, I went with a new purchase. A Kenmore HE top loader that was delivered on Saturday. So far, I love it. The price was right coming in at just under $700 including the three-year extended service contract. The Frigidaire gas dryer is still working so far. I think it would be good to have a follow-up on appliances in a few months. All this discussion was very helpful (actually better than consumer reports) when I had to purchase this washer. Cheers.
Steven says
I disagree with the line saying “front loaders clean far more better than top loaders do” you are wrong. top loaders remove dust, dirt and mud more better than top loaders do without leaving a single spot. and plus they are less expensive than front loaders. front loaders are more prone to leakage than top loaders. there is too many problems to name just don’t buy a front loader unless it’s a 4 or 5 star one.
Jean Shepherd says
Hi Kevin. I confess I did not read over 300 of these responses before sending you my washer travails! After dismal experiences with Whirlpool and Maytag top loaders without agitators I researched every source I could find for a top loader with agitator that also would allow me to completely control the amount of water, soak time, choice of number of rinses if wanted and even more! My standby Consumer Reports did not even mention what I finally purchased. Complete with stainless tub, huge capacity, PERFECT after 3 years!! Are you ready??? I bought a SPEEDQUEEN! RIGHT! I worship this gem everyday! Did I mention it came with a 5 year warranty and NO wait time for service if needed …. I haven’t.
Truly clean clothes without tangles or holes. Just like what “mom” used to have.