Last updated on August 13th, 2018
For my new kitchen, one monumental decision remains: Which tile to use for the backsplash? Gee willikers — tile comes in myriad shapes, colors, and textures! My kitchen designer at Lowe’s Home Improvement selected several tile samples for me to test drive. Would you like to see them?
Here’s where the backsplash will go. The upper and lower cabinets are white; the quartz counter top is white with gray veining.
And speaking of the quartz counter top…in a previous post, a reader (wish I could remember her name) said that I absolutely, positively, MUST use the same counter top material for my backsplash. I’d love to follow her lead, because the effect would be grand indeed! Alas, my counter top cost $6,000. The matching backsplash would cost at least $8,000, because there is no sink or cooktop to break up the necessary square footage.
I checked my savings account, and sadly, the pennies, nickles, dimes and quarters that I keep in jars in the laundry room did not add up to the aforementioned backsplash of my dreams. And that’s too bad.
Anyway, onto the design examples I brought home, along my gut reaction to each of them:Design A: Ceramic subway tiles in a gray-green hue. Every other tile is ridged.
Kevin’s opinion: MAYBE, BABY.
Design B: Marble subway tiles in gray-white.
Kevin’s opinion: BARF.
Design C: Small white ceramic tile with cute blue patterns.
Kevin’s opinion: OLD QUEEN WITH A HANGOVER.
Design D: A “basket weave” of gray and white ceramic tiles.
Kevin’s opinion: PINK FLOYD’S FAMOUS ALBUM COVER.
Against almost everyone’s advice, I sampled some plain white tile.
Design E: Common ceramic subway tile.
Kevin’s opinion: BORING BUT BEAUTIFUL.
I can easily understand why one might want an eye-catching (i.e., colorful) backsplash for an otherwise all-white kitchen. Still, I think white tile, which has been in use in kitchens for at least 100 years, offers a timeless look. I can’t imagine growing tired of it.
Now only one question remains: white tile in a glossy finish or a matte finish?
I’m thinking matte.
What say you?
xKevin
Dee says
I love the subway tile maybe not so dark a green gray but a lighter shade in the glass subway.
But it’s your kitchen so YOU should love it. So I say white matte!
Dee
Nancy C says
What about black glass tile as an accent above the stove? White subway tile everywhere else?
Beverly says
I had the same problem. Who knew there were so many choices? Ended up going with the age of my home. White beadboard. Love it. With an accent tile around the stove.
Lis says
I like subway tile but the white does not seem to work for me. It is too stark and contrast of some sort is needed especially if you are going to be filming in your kitchen. Can your desinger do a computer mock of various tiles so you can see what the choices would really look like?
Judy says
Do they make very light grey subway tiles? I like the simplicity of a matte subway tile, just a little worried there might be too much white. I’m planning on white cabinets myself so I’m really interested in your outcome. Definitely not the dark, nor the gypsy design.
cynthia corriveau says
do what makes YOU happy. You will be living with it a long time
Durf says
Wait a minute. I thought you were just going to paint so you can switch it up. No?
MWG says
One advantage to the gloss is that it is reflective and if your kitchen is dark it brightens it by reflecting light. Agree with you on the white. Have seen it with a herringbone pattern too but I think that is more $$.
Kevin Lee Jacobs says
Hi Durf – Intially I’d planned a painted backsplash. Then, after cleaning the painted surface numerous times, I decided to go with tile. I had tile in my previous kitchen, and loved it.
Dianne says
Kevin, I was thinking the same thing as Judy (above).
Although I love white subway tile (and I don’t think you can go wrong with it), I encourage you to at least look and consider the possibility of using some very light gray subway tile. I saw that in a kitchen recently and it was just gorgeous!
Diane says
Matte subway tile with a shiny black bullnose strip. Classic. Cannot be pinned down to one particular era! Add red/whatever colour through appliances, etc.
Susan Iseman says
I’m sure whatever you choose will be great, but consider the ease of cleaning the tile- kitchens get messy!
Janice in Vermont says
I agree with the recommendations for a light gray tile— a little contrast that picks up on the gray veining in your countertop. Especially as you will be filming.
Laura says
I have a similar kitchen, I used a quartzite (taj mahal) on counters and cabinets are a warm white.
I choose a matte larger subway tile I don’t recall the manufacturer but the tile was named New Yorker. If you want more info I can dig for it.
I did this 3 plus years ago and still love my kitchen every time I enter it.
I hope you are enjoying the process!
LD says
Its a very personal decision. But shiny bounces light across the room, so go shiny.
Penelope says
Go with classic white and easy to wipe down finish. Your color accents can be brought in and placed on the counters.
Mary says
Matte white subway tile. If you use under cabinet lighting the glossy will be too reflective.
Laura says
Here is a link to the tile.
I used the matte. I get a lot of compliments on it.
As you said this is a timeless classic look.
https://www.unitedtile.com/customer/untico/specpages/settecento-new-yorker-brochure.pdf
Kate says
I’d go with white or just the slightest hint of pale grey tile so they aren’t fighting with the marble countertops, but make the white the same toned grey white as the marble if you can, if not make sure it matches the painted cupboards. If you’re going subway I’d choose matte. In my kitchen (also in a very old house) I’ve gone for beadboard like another of your readers and it makes me happy every day. It’s so important to have something that isn’t fighting with the countertop for attention. If you can’t get a mock up of your kitchen try and find kitchens very similar to yours with the tiles you’re considering and see how they look. Good luck, it’s looking wonderful so far!
Karen says
If the quartz countertop is matte, then go matte white tile. If shiny countertop, then go shiny tile.
All white is nice and classic, but a herringbone design could bring a subtle twist! The increased cost of labor and materials should not be too much more.
Cathy says
Kevin, I really liked the marble subway tiles in gray and white. The glossy tiles will be much easier to wipe off because ‘things’ will cling more to the matte finish.
Val says
This is strictly my opinion but I learned that simple is better. I’ve also learned that any home decor trend now will be an eye sore in a few years, making your decor look in need of “updating”. Subway tile falls into that category. I love the look of 4×4 matte white tile. While the too much white may seem boring, splashes of brilliant color can come from “accessories”, much like a bright orange scarf with a black dress. This enables you to completely change the feel of the kitchen inexpensively without making major changes to the counter tops or backsplash.
Shirley Parran says
I just installed new subway tile backsplash. I went with the light beige with a shade lighter grout. It leaves the option open of using any kind of color in your kitchen later down the road.
Jeanie says
Basket weave tile to match the quartz…a lot less “flat.” 12×12 sheets of “woven” 1×3 quartz tiles. Tried to send picture of mine. Gives you texture.
jackie says
hey Kevin I too believe a bit of the grey in the subway tile would add a nice touch .. I always love a pop of color..all white is just to bland and boring…good luck!!
Sherlie A Magaret says
I love A but it would be a lot of pattern. White tile by itself is too stark white and you already have a lot of white. How about a stripe of A at the top and bottom or a strip of two rows centered with white subway in between. Just a suggestion. I have large light marbled with beige floor tiles for my backsplash and had a 6 x 6 decorative square medallion added at intervals on the long stretch. It does add some interest although I have stuff lined up along on the counter. Also perhaps A if it comes in a white. I love your kitchen and especially your ovens.
Linda Berry says
I would go with a very light grey, matte finish that picks up the grey veining in your counter top. My backsplash is copper and glass (small ceramic squares that are copper clad with very small copper colored glass pieces mixed in), I love how it picks up the copper veining in my Golden Typhoon granite.
Anne in Vermont zone 4/5 says
Hi Kevin, the kitchen looks good. As for a painted backsplash you will also have to clean the tile. Just wait until pasta sauce, tea or blueberry juice hits the grout (not that I speak from tile experience but touch up paint in a jar?) If you are stuck on spending more money than paint, choose matte. You will be wiping water spots off the gloss and polishing it to make it look good.
Vicki says
Consider adding a few accent tiles with some sort of pattern (though not the blue and white shown!). When we redid the kitchen in our last house, we picked a solid color and interspersed a few tiles scattered around the kitchen with painted herbs, grasses, and other nature patterns. It looked gorgeous! And it was not so expensive as we only had a limited number of accent tiles. Oh, and we did a pattern of accent tiles above the cooktop.
Patricia Sullivan says
My 2cents is…I like what comment #’s 6,8,12,15,and 21 say. Personally when my kitchen was redone I used white gloss backsplash tile because of the light issue and because it is so easy to clean…and doesn’t “grab” things like the matte tile does. Having been in the tile business for most of my life I agree with the comment that subway tile will “date” your kitchen and the 4×4 is timeless. But…by the time your subway tile “dates” your kitchen enough to speak to you then you will probably be doing a remodel again or old enough that it still looks great to you. Most of all..it is your kitchen and it needs to make you happy.
Elizabeth Workman says
Kevin, white is pure, serene, timeless. It’s welcoming, soothing. No need to be over-the-top fancy; leave that to your amazing culinary skills and personality! Matte. I don’t think you’ll be sorry, ever.
(From a fan in North Carolina…)
margaret vanhull says
Shiny grey -glass or subway-your green teakettle & green towels or bowl of green apples, limes, or herbs etc. will be the accent color-which can always be changed.
Ardelle says
Hands down – white subway glossy finish. There are so many other visuals in the kitchen that can overwhelm your space. Also, please do not do dreary colors – gray/olive – under your cabinets. If you want some zing – check out some of the thin glass accents in varying shades of white/ivory – they are awesome. However, I’d do the plain horizontal gloss subway for the long haul – if your color inclinations change through the years it will always work as you change the adjacent wallcoverings – please choose some wonderful high-quality wallcovering (also referred to as wallpaper) or paint color. It is much more changeable than tile. My white and cobalt blue tilework in my kitchen has been in place for 30 plus years and I never regret the white subway tile. Adjoining rooms have gone through dramatic color schemes through that time without a hitch. Your white kitchen is looking great – the current design magazines are really showing whites again – even though the designers tried desperately to swing to dark cabinetry a while back. There are so many less expensive ways to introduce color into your environment that are moveable and or replaceable – see, you can change out the color of your cookware overnight, along with your towels, cloths, the cutting boards, your Kitchen Aid mixer 🙂 Can’t wait to see the final pictures. Happy Dad’s day to everyone! After all, there would not be dads without all us beautiful women out there.
Margaret says
version E – white, calm,
Connie says
I recently had a kitchen reno with white cabinetry and gray veined
(marble look) quartz like yours. For the backsplash I chose 2×6 inch, I believe, light gray glass tile in a herringbone pattern. I love it! Still classic looking but with a twist.
Susan says
Hi Kevin,
Love the classic white subway tile. Matte would be my choice. If you want to do something a little special,what about a narrow band of some of those really beautiful glass tiles above center under the cabinets? Love the white kitchen. Have had two in my various homes and wish I could have done it here, but just did not work without major, major $$$$ outlay! Sigh…..
John says
I am having the same design delemma with my kitchen reno. The house is 1908, so I’m also trying to stick to classic finishes. Subway tile fits the bill, but I could do painted beadboard, too. People say subway tile will look ‘dated’ in a few years, and that’s true –in brand new, suburban kitchens– but I think it will remain timeless in a more period setting. Beadboard had a trendy revival in the 1990s, but it still stands the test of time.
My new soapstone countertops just shipped on Friday from Vermont, so I still have some time to stew about backslashes!
I think you should pick what you love, Kevin. You’ve made excellent choices thus far, and I’m sure whatever tile you pick will look marvelous.
Karen Knight says
No, no!!! Too many whites in too many different shades. I vote for the basket weave. Good luck – seriously it’s impossible – but if you are going to do a white backsplash – don’t use the subway tile – way too common these days.
Deborah says
I’d go for whatever is easiest to keep clean. Definitely not the ridged tile. I like timeless white.
Tina says
Go with a lighter shade of green in a gloss
finish. I have your same kitchen (white)
and used a pale blue 3 x 12 inch subway tile
because I like blue, and it’s beautiful. I think a little contrast is needed with all the
White. But it’s your kitchen!!
Susan says
I used a similar small patterned tile as in Design C behind my stove with larger subway tile for the rest of the backsplash. I love those small pattern tile colors and patterns. I plan to use something similar as a toe kick on our stairway with hardwood.
Martey Costello says
Hey Kevin – I have a light gray glass subway tile from Lowes. It’s classic, beautiful and easy to clean. It would pick up the gray veining in your countertop and not be boring! I think that the grey ceramic subway tile that you have up there looks inexpensive…. Good luck!
Janice says
Before you make a final decision, put out the things you will have on your countertop. You may find that the matte white is just perfect as it won’t compete with your accessories. Matte may be preferable if the lighting when filming would cause too much reflection. Lovely kitchen! Your instincts have been perfect so go with them!
Jean says
I agree with the grey glass group. Picks out the grey veins of the countertop surface. Classy. Subtle. Interesting. Versatile.
dawn says
i like that the white tile isn’t the same white as the countertop. i like the matte finish.
Kathy Sandel says
I liked the Barf one the best. Sorry. Too much white otherwise.
Elizabeth says
Matte white for less reflection when filming. Don’t forget to seal the grout to help prevent staining from sauces and grease.
Eve says
Hi Kevin, white, matte finish for kitchen backsplash an excellent choice!
Enjoying your recipes – especially the rhubarb ones.
Be fabulous.
Best Eve
anita says
Matte white tile. Less is more.
Renee Coursey says
I love your kitchen and all the white, but having white subway tile too is a little too much white for me. If you go with the white subway tile then do a border of the gray. Go with the matte finish. It will look classy and beautiful. The tile does not have to be laid horizontally, it can be done vertically for interest and to make it more fun. Are you going to put all of your things back on the counter or just leave it bare? That can make a difference too.
Rachelle Dutiel says
White subway tile in a herringbone design. White grout as well. Timeless!
Amy Dolego says
Lots of good ideas here…
Personally, my preference would be something classic because it fits the style of the house. I like continuity from room to room. While white subway tile works, that particular “white” does not work, imho. Try to closely match the white background color of the countertop, not the cabinets. It will move your eye up, rather than down. Or, see if the countertop material is made in a subway tile. I’m also not a fan of a 4″ backsplash on top of the countertop. I like the backsplash to go from under the cabinets all the way to the top of the countertop in one, continuous unbroken line. I photograph interiors for commercial clients and have seen lots of alternatives. I’m sure you’ll pick the right one. 🙂
Nickie O says
Light shiney grey would be beautiful. White would be just as nice but be careful, so many different shades of white.
Amy Dolego says
Oops, sorry…I guess I didn’t read completely. I agree with your designer that it should be the countertop material, but didn’t see where it was too pricey. Sorry!
Sandra S says
I have copper glass tiles with my grey granite countertops. Sounds weird but so beautiful. My house was built in 1921. Have you looked at glass tiles? They bring so much life to the kitchen.
Paullette McLaren says
Please please could you not a splash of colour somewhere?
Sandra says
To really get the feel of what you’re going to put there, go and buy at least 10 blocks of each pattern of tiles that you are considering and line them up along the wall, one pattern at a time, you can even get some bead board and cut it to fit between the cabinets and counter. Other than the bead board the tile blocks can be returned. Then place the items that will be residing on the counter and this will give you a better idea of how it’s going to look. It’s amazing how that one block that you may like can become “too much of a good thing” when you see a long expanse of it. Also, leave everything set up for at least 3 days and live with it in the daylight and evening. I did that when changing my counter and have never been unhappy with my choice.
Jane says
Good morning, I like the grey as it seems to pick up the grain in your counter top. I also like the idea of not being trendy but rather classic and the white is too washed out, too much white. You also might want a lighter grey but you would know if you have green in the room tying in the grey tile with a green cast. . This coming from a libra who can never make up her mind about anything, but this is my thought. Whatever u choose, it’ll look wonderful.
.
Mary W says
Janice in comment 42 had the best solution – and I do like the idea of a very thin line of narrow gray tiles in between the white rows would look great, stay in keeping with the older look and still feel fresh. (Contrasts always help in producing a great painting.) You could lay out your countertop items and put a thin grey tape on the wall then step back to see what it looks like. Good luck picking what you will be most happy with for years to come.
Diane R. says
Gloss light gray subway tile. I wouldn’t use any design tiles scattered throughout…they always get old really fast. Gloss would be easiest to keep clean also. Subway tiles have never fallen out of favor in my opinion. Color will come from accessories. Good luck Kevin, I’m sure you’ll make the perfect decision. I love your counter surfer too.
SAGE says
I don’t like any of them……
Edie says
Hey there Kevin! Well, I do believe nothing in kitchen design is timeless! White on white is beautiful but very hard to match….a little too grayish, a little too creamy… I know you have fantastic antique cabinets hiding just out of my view. Have you considered a wood look? Maybe even ceramic tile wood look? Walk on the wild side…white is too safe!
Kattrinka says
You need some kind of pop; texture, color, shine…..something to liven things up. Otherwise, it’s all bland. Each element on its own is beautiful don’t get me wrong, but adding another white/grey/blah doesn’t do it any justice.
Deb says
I recently did a similar white kitchen but broke the more common backslashes and went with an arabesque design which everyone loves.
Tried to insert a photo of it for you but this space wouldn’t take it. Let me know if you want a picture. It’s at Home Depot
Deb
Sarabeth Samoray says
You, and I, are each in historic homes. I think you should stick to all white tile – with ridges, bumps, dots, or plain — whatever – but stick to all white. Personally I prefer plain white – without the fuss – not necessarily rectangular subway. I have looked at some gorgeous small-ish square tiles lately that sure please, like half a subway size. As for adding a pop of color — a vase of flowers seasonally changed, a tier of fresh fruit — a colorful pitcher on the counter. Change up your “pops” seasonally for more fun!
No matter what – let your kitchen reflect “your” personality Kevin! Win – win!!
MaryB says
Subway tile is too popular. Remember grout cleaning, do you *really* want to go there? I’d put out my stuff and see what that looks like. Unless you plan to always have bare countertops, hahaha. Really?
Consider how it will look in your video presentations. Pattern overload? Annoying light reflections?
Is there some time limit you’re working against? Sometimes waiting is wise.
Margaret says
I LOVE the white subway tile. Very old world, never goes out of style….I like matte, but either would be beautiful! The kitchen looks wonderful so far!
Lisa says
A
I prefer the blue pattern myself, but I don’t think it “goes” with the grey veining. Besides, I like the looks of subway tile once it’s up.
Lorie says
No one has even mentioned grout color. I might choose white tile but white grout over the stove and splatter areas would not work for me. Paint is easier t keep clean than that.
Nancy E says
I just gutted my 1969 kitchen last year and replaced everything with white cabinets and stainless steel appliances. My quartz countertop has more pattern and is taupe. I used shinny white subway tile but did a inset of herringbone design over the stove and painted the walls a light taupe. Every morning when I make my cup of tea, I marvel at the change the all-white has made in the feel of my home and sets a totally different tone for the day. No matter your choice, enjoy your new kitchen.
Ginuzza says
Kevin…Be careful of too much white in a kitchen. It will end up looking like a hospital operating room. Pull the gray out of the veining in your countertops and do a classic Subway tile in that same shade of gray or a shade darker. Keep your grout lines narrow, and be sure to tell your tile setter to use a product called “grout boost” which is mixed into the grout in place of water…it will seal the grout from the inside out and you won’t have any splatters that will be able to stain it.
Try to go with smooth tiles that don’t have pits or ridges, or you will be digging food out of those areas, and they will never get completely clean. If you choose tiles with a lot of ridges, etc.., you better make very good friends with a toothbrush and Mr. clean 🙂
Anne says
I agree with Penelope … white but an occasional color (sage green is my favorite) tile here and there. Add a house plant or two, a Pink Floyd cover and you have interest and memories all at the same time. Whatever you choose will be gorgeous!
Kristina says
White subway tile is a classic background to show off pretty bowls of fruit, wooden cutting boards, colorful appliances and kitchen linens, and your amazing cooking. You will have plenty of eye-catching things in the foreground. Maybe a light gray grout for horizontal interest.
When in doubt, put your adorable pup in the picture and no one notices anything else anyway.
Danella on the Canadian west coast says
I’m thinking white matte. Your kitchen looks great!
Kate says
The white subway is timeless. All the others will automatically date your kitchen. Look through any older issues of design magazines and white always runs the test of time. Avocado or harvest gold appliances, need I say more.
Janis says
Classic white is the choice of professionals for kitchens because it works so well. My Florida kitchen reno is 20 years old but looks like it was born yesterday… or 100 years ago. Beautiful, crisp and clean. And in the words of my mother, “go glossy”. Boy, was she right. One wipe across the tiled backsplash and dinner’s messy remnants are gone. A spritz of white vinegar and wow! What a dazzle.
Maraya says
Couldn’t agree more with Janice – #42. Put everything on the counter you plan to have there all or most of the time. I know you have a lot of colorful kitchen accessories! Other than that, I like design B, which appears to pick up some of the island color, as well.
Linda says
Here’s the thing, all the designers say stick with neutral for the big things in a room and get your color with your accessories. I think that’s fabulous advice because down the road, whichever of those patterns you pick may be something you come to hate. So far as sheen, go with the same sheen you have on counters and cabinets so it blends well. I think once you get a colorful mixer (you’ve shown us plenty of those!), your towels and some other accessories in there, you will have plenty of color.
Clark Shaughnessy says
The tile with the many patterns is too busy for your kitchen. A uniform color of uniform shapes is too plain. I would go with a combination of gray and white tiles in a simple repeating pattern and probably in a couple of shapes.
Nancy Beckus says
I agree with Dee. (Comment 1) maybe slightly lighter gray. And matte. But it’s your kitchen and should reflect you! Can’t wait to see finished kitchen!
Lannie says
With so much white, I’d break it up with the grey-green. Pretty. I did our large master shower with the white subway tile… it’s ok, but I wish I’d chose another. It’s just too much white.
Mary Katherine Hook says
Too much white for filming. I think federal blue would look great.
Carol King Platt says
Hi Kevin,
When we redid my bathroom last summer, I chose marble herringbone for the floor. When it was all down and grouted, it looked like plaid! I like it, but it didn’t come out the way I expected after all that agonizing. I would go with a white subway tile, gloss, that matches the tone of either the cabinets or counter top. Or very light gray… Think of the fun you will have adding color at Christmas, Easter, Spring, Summer, Fall… It will be like having a whole different kitchen whenever your mood changes, and we will all love seeing it, too!
Love,
Carol King Platt
Maraya says
Oops! That counter color I thought I saw was only the backing the tile was sitting on. Change my opinion to light gray glass subway tile.
Richard Allegra says
After having spent too many years waiting for trains in Boston’s dank and drippy Chinatown station, I’m not a huge fan of subway tiles. However, the grey green would be my choice to give some contrast. Im thinking that you have canisters and other items that would contrast with that.
Elke says
I am asking myself the same questions, Kevin. I need a backsplash. The new white paint is not helpful when you cook spaghetti sauce.
I am looking at subway tile, in glossy white but I also like the flat white. I think I wait and see what your decision looks like.
Betty says
Go with the plain, matte white subway tile. It is a classic like you and your home!
Julie says
I’m with you, Kevin—a matte white would be best, or if the Silver Fox prefers grey, make it a lighter grey matte subway tile…not a fan of the grey you showed us. It’s going to be the background of your videos so you want eyes on you and what you’re making…no distractions or crazy lighting issues for your videotographer to be worrying about. Things..mixer or whatever..will be on the counter so too busy a pattern will have an unpleasant effect. Basic white (grey?) will be easier to live with for a long while as what you have on the counter is how you change things.
You’re brave asking for opinions..everyone’s got one!
Kate says
I love the classic look of subway tile. I do like the gray or something similar but the white will look great. If you are using grout maybe you can go with a gray grout. I agree about going with trendy things – it does become outdated that is why classic design is always a good choice.
Lynn Mc. says
I agree, the matte finish.
Charity McCauley Andeweg says
White 3 x 6 subway tile with some gray accents—how about a grey hexagon tile above the sink and/or oven framed with a grey pencil tile or run a grey pencil tile above and below a subway tile maybe 2/3 up the backsplash.
Georgette says
I think using white tile for the backsplash looks very sterile BUT is your kitchen so I vote for matte.
Joanne says
Hi Kevin, Speaking as a photographer and thinking about your kitchens appearance in your videos I would love to see something very soft. Maybe a very light soft grey to make the look of your kitchen quiet, warm, and cohesive. Think of it as the background of your videos where YOU and your delicious food stand out. You can always add pops of color with flowers, fruits, vegetables and your colorful mixer etc. Just a thought. Love your recipes, gardens, and videos!
Joy says
I used my favorite (large) artwork, framed, and fronted with big glass. Just couldn’t find tile I was wild about and kept returning to the bold flowers. I have a white kitchen, too.
Barbara. Laudun says
Use the shiny one as it will bounce back light in your kitchen, also I would put how ever many panels you need of Barf back of stove as it will add a point where the eye will stop as it looks round the kitchen. Use as a soft focal point
Margit says
I know someone who kept the backslash an enamel paint that is easy to wipe down, and then had a piece of clear glass cut to size for the area behind the stovetop. Still gives the option to switch things up with paint color and offers a bit more protection behind the stove, while keeping costs down.
Barbara laudun says
Correction. Use old queen Ann as the focal. I miss read , comes from speed reading to much. Sorry
Marlyn Anderson says
I, along with many others, think a very light gray subway tile or glass would be best. Will you have under cabinet lighting? That might make a difference with matte or glossy tiles. You have lots of color in your utensils, mixer, etc., if you plan to keep them on your counter. I love the pictures of your gardens and I’m jealous the deer don’t eat your plantings, like they do mine.
Madeleine says
So another vote for matte white. Just classic! And classy! Maybe later when the coffers are overflowing change to quartz for a super special finish.
PJ Moore says
I think the plain white tiles would be lovely. You would not be locked into a particular look or color. You would be able to add your own touch of color if you like with accessories. I am partial to red. A red geranium plant with bright green leaves or red stand mixer would make me smile.
Linda A says
I’m still in hysterics over your critiques … and do agree!
I love an all-white kitchen. What you’re thinking should work fine. Once you have some appliances or whatever else you put on the countertop, the look will be really clean and make even a bowl of fruit on the counter look spectacular.
Sorry – no opinion on matte vs gloss. Go with your gut!
Karen Thomas says
I think a primary concern should be the filming aspect. Perhaps a gloss finish would give too much reflection and appear too bright. I also agree with those who suggested a light gray of the color of the marbling in the counter. When I look at the room as a whole, I see too much white. I believe you need something to break it up but still be very classy looking, and I think a light gray matte fits the bill perfectly.
Peggy says
basket weave all the way!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Anne Walden says
I like the grey/green only a lighter shade in a matte finish. I am just not a fan of shine.
Chris says
My vote is for white matte subway tile, with grey grout that will coordinate with your countertop.
Anne Pollock says
Hop on the train to New York and check out Grand Central and ride the subways to see the original subway tiles and the patterns used. I know that is much grander than your kitchen but these are the originals and may give you some ideas. If you really want to go all out take a trip to Greece or Italy and see what they have done with tile. I love any excuse for a field trip.
If you decide that you want the plain white tiles you can always dress them up by stenciling some of them with removable paint. Something like the Greek key is timeless.
Carole says
Like the gray-green but don’t see it with the splashy colors you like in kitchen appliances and tools. I’d go with the timeless white or paint.
Carol Wardwell says
Hi Kevin–
Well although I’m crushed that you didn’t accept my recommendation for your backsplash, I’m trying to understand!! I would have said you might want some gray in the backsplash to avoid being overcome with whiteness. However, I can see that my suggestions are falling on deaf ears.
Seriously, it’s your kitchen and I’m sure it will be wonderful when you’re done–as long as you choose a glossy finish for your white backsplash tile!
Esther says
Have you considered a grout that matches the gray in the countertop?
Connie says
Do what feels right. You have to live with it. We’re going to like it, no matter what you choose. 🙂
Cindy says
Go with the white matte. There are other ways to bring in color. Best wishes.
Lisa Schuit says
I like the green but not in the patterned tiles. The solid looks nice but a color limits other choices.
Glossy subway tiles are classic and easier to clean.
Did you consider anaglypta or lincrusta? You could find a pattern that would go with the vintage home. Keep it simple and easy to clean.
Hanna says
– If you go with white tile, be sure to get grey grout. If you go with grey tile, get white grout.
– With the subways, consider ‘overlapping’ only a third, not 50% like you are holding it in the photo. It gives quite a different yet subtle look.
Jean DeSavage says
Kevin, I love the look of your choices so far. I’m with the person who said you do need some color. I like the basket weave, you could do it in two colors, white horizontal and a gray in the vertical part. It would be subtle, but it would give some movement, but not be such a stark, sterile look.
I agree with Sandra (from 6/17) to get enough of each type to set up a section with your equipment and let it set for several days. Also, take pictures of each set up, what the backsplash looks like could look totally different on camera than what it looks like as you look at it. As much as you love doing your videos, that could make a big difference for you.
You have a great design sense, look at how well you have done your home! Whatever you choose, you will do a great job. Best of luck, my prayers are with you as you make your choices.
Judy McCarrel says
I agree with you on the white tile with a matte finish. You won’t get tired of it and it won’t be poking you in the eye at some point saying “I’m an out of date trend”.
Pat says
Oh Kevin, I don’t think its the right time to make that choice. Give it some time big expensive decision. Also, wasn’t feeling your choices of backslash. Carry on.
Samantha Gray says
Love the small blue patterns as a contrast to everything else that is monochrome.
Sharon Lamoreaux says
Lots of opinions, so what is one more? When we built our white kitchen, my husband talked me out of what I really liked. We went with a more trendy glass tile with subdued colors and I hated it. Too busy! I had it all removed ( a costly mistake) and put in what I wanted originally— white glossy (classic!) subway tiles and I have loved my kitchen for over 8 years without ever rethinking it. The warmth of the wood floors and the colors from my accessories make it beautiful and classic. I coukd easily change accessory colors if I ever got bored.
Laura Clements Dixon says
Two suggestions:
1. A wooden bead board backsplash allows you to paint it any color you wish — from now til forever; it will be easy to clean; you can hammer in picture hangers to accessorize; it’s appropriate for the age of your house.
2. Consider mirroring the backsplash. You could run a quick trial to see if you like, using a few mirror squares.
3. Before you decide on anything . . . place those items you like to have on your counter top . . . then put your backsplash options in place. That will help you know how it will look on a daily basis — not just when it’s brand new.
You’ll make a success of it!
Congratulations!
Laura
bett says
pale soft grey matte subway tile. it wont fight with the countertop. ceiling could be a very very pale grey. colour added in accessories. fruit, flowers, art, tea towls etc… lighting important too & then there is the grout… light grey or white
i love my matte subway tiles 7 years later. they always look clean & unobtrusive.
Susi says
I am partial to the gray- green subway tile for the contrast it will provide. I think the all over white is just too stark and cold. And you are such a warm guy!
Christine D says
Speaking from experience do not use ridged tiles. Smooth is much easier to clean!
LISE G. says
Hi Kevin! We remodeled/updated our 1985 kitchen just a few years ago. I took into consideration the colors of the new floor, existing cabinets, new countertops and adjacent rooms when picking out a backsplash. Most everything is white except for the floor and we chose narrow glass tiles which are about 1” wide in an assortment of 5 neutrals and we just love it! Whatever you choose, just make sure it’s something you think you won’t tire from as it’s a big investment.
Paul Butchart says
Be sure to check out Heritage Tile for subway tiles and other historically accurate tiles which have a square flat edge which sits flush and does does not curve over like most tiles practically eliminating the need for mortar between the tiles. Their floor tile can be made to be completely smooth across the surface with no dip that one finds between the tiles of modern replicas. https://heritagetile.com/
Cynthia Kammann says
Your new kitchen is the bee’s knees, but I’m not sure you’ve found the best backsplash option yet. So, I say keep shopping.
I think smaller tiles that bring some light to the space. Maybe glass?
I think something that will bring balance, or at least soften the strong horizontal lines of the countertop and the bottom of the cabinets.
Maybe tiles that bring a more organic movement.
I haven’t read the previous replies and hope my straightforward opinion is not offputting.
Connie M. says
I like D! It will give you the depth and interest you want in your kitchen. Could I suggest you post another picture of the D selection, but stand back further so we can see it against the white cabinets. I think if you just do white tile, you’ll end up with a boring looking kitchen. I redid my kitchen with dark cabinets and a white-ish Caesarstone quartz. It is not cheap and like you I decided not to do the backsplash in the quartz due to cost. So, I ended up going with some Italian white subway type tiles. It looks great, BUT I have dark cabinets to offset the tile and quartz countertop. You need some pizazz – the meaning of which is energy; vitality; vigor – attractive style; dash; flair. I think all of those words fit you to a T, Kevin. 🙂
Allison says
The white is beautiful so far, but you need to add some color. We just did a clear sage green glass subway tile (12x12x8″ “Arctic Ice” from Home Depot) and it turned out beautifully. Something muted and sophisticated like that would be a great option.
Patricia C says
We “refreshed” my older kitchen a few years ago with new countertops, backsplash, flooring and new hardware on the older but still good looking oak cabinets. The backsplash tiles we picked are cream colored subway tile but with a crackled glaze shiny finish. Everyone loves the way they look. It is my favorite part of the update. The tile was imported from Spain and was a bit more expensive than the subway tile with the plain finish but not terribly outrageous. Email me if you want more info. I think it would be lovely in your kitchen especially that it has the look of antique China. It might even come in other colors but I love anything creamy looking.
Anita says
I prefer the idea of gray subway tiles for the backsplash – will tie together the white cabinets with the marble countertop – and all your stainless steel (which is gray too, too after all!)
I think the white backsplash is too much white – no matter what finish or pattern you choose.
Annette Loubert says
I like the basket weave, we put an even more dramatic one in our mostly white kitchen and are very happy with it, it is different than what you see everywhere else.
Edna says
Hi Kevin, After reading some of the comments I am in a tizzy! I am leaning towards GLOSSY WHITE WITH A FEW TILES OF SAGE GREEN AS AN ACCENT. You have to live with it!
Mary Alice Yost says
I vote for lighter gray glossy.
Lisa says
I think the contrast of a neutral pale grey tile would be wonderful and perhaps grey grout for a more forgiving clean-up? Or perhaps if you would really prefer white subway, you could use medium grey grout to break up the color.?
Jan Jacklin says
Lowe’s…a great place… but they didn’t do you justice with the tile… if those are the choices…. I’m with you with the white…You can have color with towels, mixer, Vitamix & flowers of course…..
Justine says
Hi Kevin,
Forgive me for offering up an option you didn’t give us. I had stainless steel tiles in my kitchen and LOVED the way it seemed to enhance light, tie all the stainless steel appliances together, and offer a “clean” (sterilized, yet warm) effect. Super easy to keep clean… It would blend so well with your beautiful marble counter. I love working with the elements (wood, stone, metal). Here’s an image that might show you what I mean. https://www.subwaytileoutlet.com/gallery/Stainless-Steel-1-x-3-Kitchen-Backsplash.html
If I may say, I think the “white” of the tile you show in the photo (E) is too dissimilar to the soft light grey-white of the marble. Using the stainless steel tiles would imho break up and tie together the various elements at play in your beautiful new kitchen.
GOOD LUCK (especially with so many opinions!! teeheehee)
Lisa says
Gray glass tiles or matte finish gray ….too much white…need to break it up…I like the subway style and have irregular shape white against black jet mist counter.and white cotton subway in my shower …
Lauren Anderson says
Is there any way, you could randomly scatter the cute blue patterns in amongst the classic white tiles. I think that would keep it from looking like a dream sequence in a Woody Allen flick. Otherwise, I like your redo.
Annie B says
Matte. And thank you for making me laugh out loud on a sad sad day. Beautiful kitchen.
Patricia says
Kevin,
I preferred the first gray-green one, although I lean to being more gray than green. I think the contrast makes everything stand out. I also liked the woman’s suggestion of stainless steel tiles. Had not seen these before. In any case, it is YOUR kitchen and you must be happy. So white it is; I’m hoping you choose matte. Cannot wait to see the finished project. Love your website.
Patricia
Gale Dickert says
So many options! Now, that you are thoroughly bamboozled with ideas, I’d just suggest that you use a tile with a finish that coordinates well w/your countertop –and perhaps add a narrow line of contrasting tile in a darker color to add interest. But, I’m sure, whatever you end up choosing, with your great taste, it will be beautiful Can’t wait to see it!
Kara says
My 2 cents: white, glossy subway— ETERNALLY classic, easy to clean, bright, light reflective. Color, if you want, the grout; YOU are all the color the space needs.
Any texture back there is more difficult to maintain than a flat surface.
Your choices so far are peachy-nifty, are essential Kevin: just right.
Rosemarie in rural Kansas City says
Loved the backsplash sampling
I tend to go to boring plain things so I vote for white matte
Matte is what we put in our walk in shower – doesn’t show spots, etc like shiny would – and it’s 15 years old and looks brand new
Tend to like things simple – aka white – can always dress up or down – change of seasons, etc
And you’ll never get tired of it
The grout should be chosen carefully – we used a light (very light) grey so it’s barely noticeable
Another point for white is that no matter what stain you might get -like I did many moons ago making my first (and only) batch of grape jelly – is that you can bleach, bleach, bleach
As I said – I really like simple things
But LOVE, love, love your new kitchen
How lucky you are!
Lynn says
I had white tiles in my last house, and of course white grout. I loved the tiles bu it was a menace trying to keep that grout clean.
I’d say go for matte tiles to avoid problems when filming.
Brenda from Sacramento,CA says
Hi Kevin,
We recently re-did our kitchen and I have the white cabinets and white subway tile. My contractor choose the smaller subway tiles not the usual size. They are perfect for my small kitchen and he choose a light gray grout which is perfect because it pulls out the gray in my counter tops which is a brown / multicolored top. We choose a pretty blue for the walls which makes the white cabinets and subway tile stand out. Love my kitchen. You will never regret the white subway tiles. I would choose matte.
By the way I liked the Old Queen with the hangover blue tiles from your samples.
Mariann says
Dear Kevin
a few things come to my mind – I have a similarly white grey kitchen, and I wish I had the occasional splash of sunshine in there – how about the white tiles mixed with a small number of bright yellow? It lifts the mood …
Matte or bright tiles: Make intensive tests with food that colours heavily – tomato sauce, beetroot juice (or little morsels after grating) and see if they leave no stains, when left sitting there only for 30 minutes. This would be my worry with matte tiles. The same for the grouting. Make sure you have large tiles – less grouting. And pay attention to the material of the grouting – how easy can it be cleaned? Can silicone be used instead of the natural material?.
All the best in your decision making, your kitchen looks great!
Cookbook Collector says
Aside from the cost, like I said a month ago, the slab would have avoided all these tile decisions…but still so glad for you that you have decided to finish it off. That said, assuming you can find the right shade of white subway tiles that will go with both the cabinets and counters, that could be the most practical way to go. Raised 3 dimensional tile will collect dirt and grime so keep the tile selection flat and simple. I had never noticed your old kitchen’s white tile backsplash with white grout before going back to view old posts. So, to notice the new backsplash, going with narrow grout lines in a nice shade of grey colored grout would add just enough texture and design interest but not be too overwhelming. While glossy tile might bring in more light, there is already plenty of light reflection from all the white. The matte finish will eliminate unwanted reflections during video recording, minimize seeing the water spots and splattered grease, and be better suited to the era of you home. For the cooking videos, I would think the focus should be on you and the food and using the backsplash and the rest of the new kitchen as a back drop. Even for your everyday kitchen use, I would think you want to come into the kitchen and see THE kitchen, not just some bold, busy, or loud backsplash each and every time. In the end, you have to decide what you want to live with, both today and years out from now. I think you have already decided and with asking for inputs, you are just fine tuning it. I love classic and timeless that does translate to boring but beautiful! So, go for it!
Peggy says
Your kitchen is lovely and most important is for you to feel comfortable and happy there. Go with whatever your heart is telling you and bon cuisine!
Linda D says
I would suggest glass tile not ceramic. Large preferably, less grout lines. Glass tile give depth to the area. So my choice would be large, white, glass subway tile. I have them in my house and they’re beautiful. Good luck, you have great taste. I’m sure you’ll pick a winner.
Juls Owings says
I have white gloss tile as my back splash…they do show water spots but it’s easy to wipe off on a daily bases. My friend has matte finish, when she cleaned last week she was shocked to realize how dirty it was, she couldn’t remember the last time she wiped it down .
SO do you want to be reminded to wipe it down or not reminded LOL
SMILE
Ardelle says
After reading all these comments -Whew! try to steer away from grays or ‘grayed’ colors – most people ultimately are disappointed as it is dreary/depressing especially on rainy or snowy weather days. Subway -glossy – tile doesn’t ‘date’ a home – it has been used as long as I have been a designer/remodeling contractor. See my previous comment. I’m sure your head is spinning by now – good luck Kevin.
Theresa Ryan says
Sorry – I’m super fond of the Pink Floyd, but you should go with your gastronomic gut! Good luck!
Growing my own says
I don’t have an opinion on the finish of the subway, but you can bring your grey in with the grout.
This is the part I hate about decorating. ALL THE DECISIONS. And, unlike paint, you will have to live with your bad choice or regret for awhile.
I hope you and your decision will live happily, peacefully ever after.
Marilyn says
I thought the patterned tile could look great, since you do have so much white and the white and gray countertop. But when I saw it in the “try out” I changed my mind and somehow don’t like it. I like the basket weave but you clearly are already half persuaded by the plain white .
I say: go with your decorating gut! It’s your kitchen; you’ll be the one spending time in it.
It is so wonderful to have a sparkling new kitchen! And yours is beautiful.
Sheri Rice says
We did simple white subway tiles in our last house in the kitchen and LOVED it. The last thing you want is for the backsplash to stand out and command attention. So my vote is the subway tile. My only suggestion is to consider doing something decorative behind your cooktop range. In our new house, we have quartz that matches the countertops in a strip adjacent to/directly above the counter, and then it’s beadboard for another 12 inches, and then wall. But on the side where the range is located, there is a beautiful “centerpiece” of decorative tile that features raised relief tiles with animals, bordered with tiles that look like twisted rope. Happy to email you a photo if you’d like to see it.
Suzanne Gravelle says
Maybe use darker grout.
I did a backslash of subway tiles but in stainless steel
It would go well in your kitchen
Darcee says
No on anything except maybe the Pink Floyd Wall. Go back to the drawing board and get creative. This will be in your kitchen a long time so you cannot settle. It must be fabulous.
Denise says
https://na.pergo.com/-/media/Images/Pergo/Product%20Catalog/Product%20Images/Pergo%20Portfolio/blueprint/786007_blueprint_swatch_thb%20jpg.jpg.
Someone I know used this as a backsplash…It was striking
Mary S. says
I like the subway tile best. The blue is too weird and too traditional with your clean white. The white is too monochromatic. The others don’t work for me. I have a grey mottled subway tile with a hint of green (not shiny) that I love! Never tire of it. Good luck with your choices! But the designer part of me (a la my visual daughter) says you need contrast, simplicity and something with a little color.
Brenda says
I think white subway tile – the plain stuff – nothing fancy – is always a good option. The colors tend to get tiring after a while, I think and what color you liked today, you may not like in a few years. Matching your counters would be nice but plain white subway tile is what I would choose. I have dark quartz countertops in my renovated kitchen and the plain, white subway is a classic look to me. Besides, white subway tile is $0.22 a tile at our Home Depot.
Franceen Elias-Stein says
Kevin, I’m attaching an image of another option that may work for you. In case you cannot open this file, I will describe it (I have this in my kitchen and I love it). It has the clean look of white subway tile with 6 rows of black and grey glass tiles, silver and gunmetal metal tiles and clear glass tiles which are all 4 1/2″ x 1/4″ long. You can find many such tiles in different colour combinations and materials. It may be worth checking out before going ahead with your backsplash.
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ui=2&ik=7db8a207bc&view=att&th=164149332f27c918&attid=0.1&disp=safe&realattid=f_jikpm4my0&zw
Jan says
So many comments to read…I pick the white matte, clean and classy.
Christine says
If you go with a light great, just make sure you are going with one that complements the grey of the counter. Is it cold grey or warm grey? I can’t tell from your pictures. Also I would suggest getting one matte tile and one glossy tile and spill spaghetti sauce on both and leave it for awhile. Then try to wipe it off. That will tell you which one will function the best. Good Luck!
Denise Bennett says
The white seems to be too plain with your all white kitchen. Try the first choice or something similar.
Casey C says
I have now orchestrated the kitchen overhaul (down to the studs) in 7 houses — mostly recently 2017 so I know the struggle you are experiencing with the tile choices. BTW, everything you have done so far is outstanding. And that is why you probably don’t want to hear what I am about to say: can you deal with waiting on the backsplash for 6 months to a year until your laundry room jars have a few more pennies in them so you can get the same quartz slab for the backsplash that you already have on the countertops? If you can go ahead and charge the cost of the slabs needed thru the fabricator and then pay off monthly (and I am not a proponent of credit card balances but the availability of the same slab material is critical here), it would be the ideal solution as your other reader has already suggested. If you proceed now with a tile option that you are not 100% confident about, you may regret it. If you can live without the backsplash for a few months more but have the material safely purchased and housed at the fabricator until the day you can afford to have it cut and installed in your home, you may feel that the wait was worth it. I’d send you the coins in my own laundry room jar if it would help!
Alexis says
Just weighing in after a quick read of ever so much advice….I have white subway tiles, but glossy not matte. They are a breeze to clean so they work for me. As for additional interest, color, etc. I have a stainless steel shelf above my stove that has some of my collection of pig carved bread boards and ceramic pigs. They add some color and lots of interest. As offered by others, go with your gut. Your kitchen, your call. You’ll love what you decide!!!!!
Lorelei says
Oh, Kevin, I just LOVE the white and blue patterned tiles! Unique, like you! Plus, I think it fits in just perfectly with the rest of the house. Victorians and Greek Revivals are full of little pockets of ornamentation!
I don’t know about you, but “OLD QUEEN WITH A HANGOVER” evokes a kitchen with a traditional aesthetic, but also of fun and whimsy. In other words, a perfect match for you and your marvelous home!
P.S. I don’t think anyone would complain if you included one picture of Avery with every post.
JaneGrace Bowman says
White, matte. Clean, easy to keep clean. Classic. You will have plenty of beautiful colored appliances to add the color. Unless it is stellar tile, don’t settle. Love the white.
Debra says
We have white subway tile in our bathroom—chose matte. Doesn’t show fingerprints. The matte is actually a satiny finish. Works great for us.
MaryEllen Warkentin says
I would pick the pale green with no lined pattern to it. As someone said you can accessorize with the items adorning your counter top. The other option I like was to use beadboard backing appropriate for the age of the house. Keep it simple but elegant .
Cynthia Gruetzmacher says
For me I would need a bit of color. How bout a very pale lilac which I think would be nice with the gray. Also consider pale celery green. You can still change out out accessories for a different look when you want. Also I like the cobalt border with white tile.
Can’t wait to see what you decide.
Susan says
Sigh. Still can’t forgive you for the white kitchen. Alas.
Petera Mironchik says
I liked the basketweave. Timeless. The gray green will become passe in a few years, the blue pattern can get boring in a few years and just plain white looks too instititional with your all white kitchen which I like. The little bit of gray in the basket weave also picks up the gray of the beautiful counter top you chose.
Rose says
You’ve probably made your decision by now, but I just wanted to say I put in an all white kitchen with white Silestone counters 11 years ago. I didn’t want any backsplash, not even the little one you have with your counter, because I get tired of patterns and colors quickly and hate grout, so I chose paint – semigloss white – easy to wash easy to repaint when I want change. I have not gotten tired of the color, nor had to repaint the white. I cook every day, and so far I have been able to wipe off any spaghetti sauce and grease with a sponge. I still love my no backsplash.
Ardelle says
🙂 🙂 🙂 !!!!!
Kirsten Berwick says
I vote white shiny, minimal grout. You will thank me on the 20th dark winters day in a row, when you are tossing around a robust red wine sauce to nap the roast beast!!
Cookbook Collector says
A thought on classic tile patterns… first thoughts are always horizontal subway tiles but there is another classic, 4 1/2″ square tiles run in diamond pattern as seen here:
https://www.pinterest.com/pin/767160117749713201/
Because of the already short backsplash you have in place, that leaves less visual space up to the upper cabinets. The diamond pattern still keep it classic but give the space an illusion of more height between the counter and upper cabinets. And, while focal areas can be beautiful, but they can also be distracting. So not to cut up the kitchen’s small running counter space too much, by just having a continuous running diamond pattern would make the area appear larger instead of chopped up with this and that design over the sink and/or over the stove.
Constantine says
Hi Kevin,
My 2 cents: your kitchen (from the pictures) is very white. It reads as cold. the butcher block counter brings in warmth. My suggestion is to look for a tile that is warm – something that has variations of browns/tans/beige. Could be a natural stone or a ceramic.
Good luck!
Jan says
I like the classic white tile idea, probably in matte, shiny would be a little too “bus station” for me. What color grout are you going to use? If you match the tiles, it will just blend in. But, if you go for a grey grout, you’ll have a subtle (or maybe not) pattern going on.
Sheila says
Design E. It’s clean, and beautiful. I love the kitchen.
Julie R says
My opinion is go with your gut feeling on this one, Kevin. Pick what ever color and finish of backsplash tile that you can picture yourself living with for many years to come. If I were re-doing a kitchen, I would go for a timeless look, and have fun with accessories, that can easily be changed. I can’t wait to see what you decide on.
DJ Todd says
You seem to be in sync with your older home and I believe it will speak to you about this tile issue. Old houses have opinions!!
bren english says
my vote is the white subway tile-gloss finish-love it-timeless and classy.
Marcia Colby Truslow says
What’s your favorite color, Kevin? Use that as a backsplash, or a piece here and there to give some spice to the white and grey. I am a color person and find that monotones are blah without something that says, “Wow”. Just my feeble opinion.
Susan says
Kevin
I would look for a beveled pearlized crackle ( almost looks like crazing)subway tile with light gray grouting
It will give it some visual interest.
Maybe add some Mackenzie – Child’s canisters to the counter.
Good luck
Susan
Carla says
White matte is perfect and will look comfortable in your old home. Your eyes won’t tire of it and it won’t be a passing fad.
Kay says
Kevin, my kitchen redo has been in stops & starts over several years but I have a little in common with yours. A new stainless steel range (would love to have 2 wall ovens!!) White walls (painted panelling in our old farmhouse & I finally convinced the Farmer to let me paint the 6 doors that open into/out of this room. No more blobs of orangeish pine when you walk into the room.) Instead of a wooden island for the natural element I have golden pine cupboards that my FiLaw made years ago. I just couldn’t paint those. And we went with semi-glossy subway tile with white grout for our backsplash. I love the cleanness of it.
Your new sink intrigues me. It doesn’t hardly look big enough for a soup bowl from the photos. I’m pinning the photo for future inspiration.
Happy kitchen times!